Limits on the Amending Power: A Comparative Study of India's Basic Structure Doctrine, Germany's Eternity Clause and Colombia's Substitution Doctrine

Formal amendment procedures are designed to allow a constitution to change, but they have been repeatedly used to dismantle checks and balances, capture judiciaries and extend executive tenure. This paper examines three responses to that problem: Germany’s express eternity clause in Article 79(3) of the Basic Law, India’s judicially developed Basic Structure Doctrine, and Colombia’s Substitution Doctrine. It also traces the journey of these models to Bangladesh and Malaysia. The study finds that the three doctrines are founded on the same premise: a power derived from a constitution cannot be used to destroy or supersede the original constituent power from which it is derived. They vary in the source of the limit, the identification of the protected core and the institutional risks they pose. Germany gives textual certainty, but the clause still needs to be interpreted. India provides flexibility at the cost of an open-ended list and the prospect of judicial supremacy, as the NJAC verdict demonstrates. Colombia provides a structured test, but its fundamental notion of an “essential element” is vague. The paper takes seriously the counter-majoritarian objection that unelected courts invalidate amendments. It concludes that such limits are defensible only where courts employ them sparingly to protect the democratic order itself. It proposes a “Democratic Minimum Test”, under which a court can strike down an amendment only if it poses a clear threat to the open political processes necessary to challenge and change the law at a later time. The paper concludes with some practical proposals for judicial restraint.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
International Journal of Law Management & Humanities
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.63108/ijlmh.13266
Primary Topic
Comparative constitutional jurisprudence studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Limits on the Amending Power: A Comparative Study of India's Basic Structure Doctrine, Germany's Eternity Clause and Colombia's Substitution Doctrine

Apoorva Mishra, Manek
2 links
International Journal of Law Management & Humanities
Comparative constitutional jurisprudence studies
article

Limits on the Amending Power: A Comparative Study of India's Basic Structure Doctrine, Germany's Eternity Clause and Colombia's Substitution Doctrine

Apoorva Mishra, Manek
article en

Abstract

Formal amendment procedures are designed to allow a constitution to change, but they have been repeatedly used to dismantle checks and balances, capture judiciaries and extend executive tenure. This paper examines three responses to that problem: Germany’s express eternity clause in Article 79(3) of the Basic Law, India’s judicially developed Basic Structure Doctrine, and Colombia’s Substitution Doctrine. It also traces the journey of these models to Bangladesh and Malaysia. The study finds that the three doctrines are founded on the same premise: a power derived from a constitution cannot be used to destroy or supersede the original constituent power from which it is derived. They vary in the source of the limit, the identification of the protected core and the institutional risks they pose. Germany gives textual certainty, but the clause still needs to be interpreted. India provides flexibility at the cost of an open-ended list and the prospect of judicial supremacy, as the NJAC verdict demonstrates. Colombia provides a structured test, but its fundamental notion of an “essential element” is vague. The paper takes seriously the counter-majoritarian objection that unelected courts invalidate amendments. It concludes that such limits are defensible only where courts employ them sparingly to protect the democratic order itself. It proposes a “Democratic Minimum Test”, under which a court can strike down an amendment only if it poses a clear threat to the open political processes necessary to challenge and change the law at a later time. The paper concludes with some practical proposals for judicial restraint.

International Journal of Law Management & HumanitiesVol. 9(VI)
University of Delhi (IN)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions
Comparative constitutional jurisprudence studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon