Disentangling Cultural Likert Response Styles, Multi-Informant Discrepancy Polarity, and Institutional Support Regimes Across Four Anglophone K–12 Systems: A Coordinated Integrative Data Analysis of 2,280 Families
Cross-national K–12 comparisons across Anglophone systems routinely equate scalar invariance with unbiased observed scores, overlooking culturally patterned Likert scale usage, domain-specific parent–youth discrepancy reversals, and heterogeneity within pooled Commonwealth samples. Using coordinated Integrative Data Analysis (IDA) across four Wave 1 cohorts—burnout (HABRI), parenting (HPSSI), executive functioning (HEFSI), and self-regulated learning (HSRLI)—this study analyzed 311,840 ordinal responses from N = 2,280 families (1,618 Grades 4–12 dyads and 662 Grades K–3 parents in the United States [n = 1,377], United Kingdom [n = 580], Canada [n = 279], and Australia/Other Commonwealth [n = 44]) plus J = 480 Core-60 Differential Item Functioning (DIF) parameters. Multi-process IRTree models revealed monotonic U.S.-to-Commonwealth shifts from extreme (F[3, 2276] = 22.81, p < .001) to midpoint responding (F[3, 2276] = 18.53, p < .001) and strong household concordance (r = .749–.792); purifying response styles eliminated apparent U.S. executive-function leads while sharpening Canadian and British burnout elevations. Directional parent–youth discrepancies inverted polarity between burnout and home safety (F[9, 1599] = 2.40, p = .011), British profile agreement dipped at ages 9–11 (p = .011), and recreational screen time interacted with national special-education support (F[3, 1604] = 6.20, p < .001). Open-access multi-language instrument forms, scoring documentation, baseline invariance summary matrices (N = 3,809), and copyright-holder adaptation permissions (ITC Guideline PC-1) are archived at https://openinventories.org.
Authors
- Alexander Kuznetsov (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0002-6652-3544)
Publication Details
- Journal
- SocArXiv (OSF Preprints)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.31235/osf.io/2muq4
- Primary Topic
- Psychometric Methodologies and Testing
- Type
- preprint