Державний фінансовий контроль (аудит) за видатками на інформатизацію кроків Плану України в межах Ukraine Facility
The Ukraine Facility links funding for Ukraine to the implementation of the Ukraine Plan steps and to the protection of the European Union’s financial resources against the risks of fraud, corruption, conflict of interest and double funding. A significant share of the Ukraine Plan steps involves the creation or modernisation of information systems. Such expenditure produces results that cannot be verified by inspection or measurement, and its development cost cannot be verified by comparison with similar purchases in Prozorro. The article aims to develop a methodological approach to the state financial audit of expenditure on IT-related Ukraine Plan steps that combines COBIT 2019 IT governance criteria, Arachne+ risk indicators and economic tests of IT expenditure, and to verify its applicability on a single step. The study uses content analysis of the Framework Agreement, Regulation (EU) 2024/792, Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine Resolutions No. 1318 and No. 1483, the Audit Strategy for the Implementation of the Ukraine Plan and the methodological recommendations of the State Audit Service of Ukraine; classification of steps according to formalised rules; expert mapping "step content – COBIT 2019 process – Arachne+ indicator" under explicitly defined selection rules; a coverage test and a demonstration case. Of the 178 items in the list "Ukraine Plan Steps" (as amended in 2026), 47 involve IT-related measures or expenditure, and 17 of them (category A) entail the creation, modernisation or launch of IT systems. The scientific novelty lies in a methodological solution that goes beyond systematising known instruments. A two-contour audit model for an IT step is proposed, in which the contour of process capability (COBIT 2019) and the contour of counterparty integrity (Arachne+) are assessed separately and combined under a one-way influence rule: low capability of key processes caps the level of confidence in the internal control system and raises audit priority, whereas high capability does not cancel a triggered risk indicator. Rules are defined for prioritising audits and for the targeted inclusion of contracts in the sample. Six economic tests (expected cost, actual costs, life-cycle cost, volume of work performed, justification of contract amendments, effectiveness of operation) are developed to fill the gaps of both instruments. A base set of 21 COBIT 2019 processes (a mandatory core, processes at the level of the responsible body and the Plan, and step-specific processes) is formed; counting and selection rules for Arachne+ indicators are formulated (64 of the 84 items of the consolidated list are applicable), and it is shown that Arachne+ contains no performance indicators for information systems, does not assess development cost and does not cover pre-procurement stages. The applicability of the approach is demonstrated through the chain "risk – criterion – audit procedure – evidence – possible conclusion" for step 4.10 "Register of bank accounts and safes". The results can be used to update the methodological recommendations of the State Audit Service of Ukraine for auditing category A steps.
Authors
- Ольга Кучма (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7983-7545)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Вісник Академії праці, соціальних відносин і туризму. Серія: економіка, психологія та управління.
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.54929/3041-2390-2026-10-03-03
- Primary Topic
- Economic Issues in Ukraine
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00