From Local Insufficiency to Collective Necessity: Investigating the Scientific Conditions for Field-Based Models of Language and Intelligent Systems
This conceptual research paper investigates when local descriptions of language-mediated and multimodal intelligent systems are insufficient for mission-level questions and what additional evidence would be required to justify a distinct Field-based account. The inquiry separates three propositions that are often conflated: insufficiency of a specified local observation, necessity of additional collective information, and incremental scientific value of Large Language Fields (LLFs) or Large Signals Fields (LSFs). The account also reconstructs the dated conceptual lineage: the published LLF formulation of October 2025, closely followed by Field Intelligence, Field-Driven Design and Field Definition Language, and the named LSF generalization of February 2026. Historical precedence of this stated formulation is distinguished from global first-invention claims, evidence of influence on later research and independent experimental validation. We formalize mission-relative sufficiency using observational equivalence classes, provide a simple indistinguishability proposition, and distinguish behavioral truth, observability, evidentiary warrant, and normative admissibility. A linked sequence of candidate qualification procedures examines minimal relational augmentation, regime transitions, collective observability, claim revision, mission identity, and prospective discriminative consequences. Four original schematic figures clarify the argument and a comparative evaluation design. Existing distributed-systems theory, causal abstraction, statistical sufficiency, provenance, belief revision, contract-based design, and AI-agent evaluation constitute substantive comparators rather than weak baselines. We propose controlled paired histories, independently designed comparison arms, risk–coverage analysis, calibration, transfer tests, and cost accounting, with explicit opportunities for a conclusion of no Field-specific requirement. No empirical evaluation, formal novelty proof, or independent validation has been performed. The contribution is a bounded, falsifier-oriented research framework for investigating the scientific conditions under which collective representations are necessary and for determining whether LLF/LSF approaches add value beyond conventional alternatives.
Authors
- Rogério Figurelli (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0002-5726-1765)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24399757
- Primary Topic
- Diverse Interdisciplinary Research Studies
- Type
- preprint