The net contribution of pesticides to agriculture
Pesticides provide important economic benefits for agricultural production. However, they also have well-documented environmental and social effects. We here show that these effects are often ignored when evaluating pesticides' contribution to agricultural production, while their consideration is related to lower estimates of pesticides' contribution on average. We base our analysis on a conceptual model for comparing and assessing the net pesticide contribution to agriculture. Based on the conceptual model, we then systematically review the global literature (9606 reviewed, 66 retained) and synthesize how economic, environmental, and social dimensions are jointly evaluated and quantitatively integrated. Our review shows that integrated assessments have only recently appeared and are less abundant. We then extract 179 estimates on pesticide productivity from the reviewed articles and conduct a meta-analysis, controlling for a wide range of methodological and production system characteristics. The results reveal substantial heterogeneity across estimation dimensions, methodological approaches, outcome measurements, and production contexts. Importantly, pesticide contribution estimates vary systematically depending on whether environmental or social impacts are considered. More concretely, we find that studies, which only consider the economic dimension, on average find pesticide productivity to be higher. Our findings have important implications for future assessments of pesticides' contribution to agriculture and resulting policy and extension recommendations. We discuss methodological and data limitations, as well as important ways forward for future assessments.
Authors
- Xiaojie Wen (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6847-1157)
- Niklas Möhring
Institutions
- University of Bonn (DE)
Publication Details
- Journal
- bonndoc (University of Bonn)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.48565/bonndoc-1032
- Primary Topic
- Sustainable Agricultural Systems Analysis
- Type
- preprint