ULM-Bench: A Preregistered Benchmark and Audit Protocol for Ontological Coherence in Language Models

This record contains the complete artifact bundle for the arXiv preprint ULM-Bench: A Preregistered Benchmark and Audit Protocol for Ontological Coherence in Language Models (Mark JJ McCormack, independent researcher).Contents: - ULM v1.0 — a versioned Hegelian category graph (Logic → Nature → Spirit) with 654-slot grid, 555 uncontested verified slots, 53 pending, 28 gaps, 18 contested, 342 application mappings, and 24 cross-cutting Universals. Released as JSON (ulm_v1.json), CSV position tables, raw exports, and JSON Schema. - OMS Reference Implementation — deterministic Python reference for the Ontological Match Score (oms_reference.py), computing direction, distance, and triad-integrity losses against the sequestered ULM graph. - Semantic Logic Mapping (SLM) Specification — formal parser spec (PARSER_SPEC.md), relation inventory, worked examples, failure taxonomy, and JSON Schema (slm.schema.json). - ULM-Bench Benchmark Specification — three task families (Static Retrieval, Cross-Domain Normative Dilemmas, Ontological Rupture), item schema, four conditions (Ungrounded, BFO/CCO, GraphRAG, ULM), six controls, and eight primary endpoints. - Preregistered Confirmatory Protocol — \$25k study design with hypotheses (H-01–H-19), power analysis (N=194/condition for 10pp effect), go/no-go gates (Parser F1 ≥ 0.85, κ ≥ 0.67, OMS AUC ≥ 0.80), and falsification criteria. - Pilot Results — 200 items × 4 conditions; L condition 52% OMS pass (0.707 mean), U/B/G 100% abstain. - Audit Scripts — ulm_audit.py (14,940 checks, 0 errors), build_ulm.py (deterministic builder). - Gold Sets & Annotation Manual — 50-sentence gold set with adjudicated SLMs (κ = 0.82), coding manual.License: Sublation License v4.0 (this record). The preprint is licensed separately under arXiv's terms.Status: Proposal and preregistration. No confirmatory experiments have been run. All artifacts are released for independent verification and execution. ------------------------------------------------------------ Status: Proposal and preregistration. Simulations have been run. No confirmatory experiments have been run. All artifacts released for independent verification and execution under the Sublation License v4.0. Citation: McCormack, M.J.J. (2026). ULM-Bench: A Preregistered Benchmark and Audit Protocol for Ontological Coherence in Language Models. Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23324479 Keywords: language model evaluation, ontological coherence, benchmark, preregistration, Hegel, dialectical logic, AI safety, deception detection, semantic parsing, Anthropic, Safety By Design, Safety-By-Design, BFO, Basic Formal Ontology, gBFO, Genuine Basic Formal Ontology, AI Alignment, ASI Alignment, Super Intelligence, Artificial Super Intelligence, AI Priors, Aristotle, Plato,

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24405603
Primary Topic
Topic Modeling
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

ULM-Bench: A Preregistered Benchmark and Audit Protocol for Ontological Coherence in Language Models

McCormack Mark
1 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Topic Modeling
preprint

ULM-Bench: A Preregistered Benchmark and Audit Protocol for Ontological Coherence in Language Models

McCormack Mark
preprint en

Abstract

This record contains the complete artifact bundle for the arXiv preprint ULM-Bench: A Preregistered Benchmark and Audit Protocol for Ontological Coherence in Language Models (Mark JJ McCormack, independent researcher).Contents: - ULM v1.0 — a versioned Hegelian category graph (Logic → Nature → Spirit) with 654-slot grid, 555 uncontested verified slots, 53 pending, 28 gaps, 18 contested, 342 application mappings, and 24 cross-cutting Universals. Released as JSON (ulm_v1.json), CSV position tables, raw exports, and JSON Schema. - OMS Reference Implementation — deterministic Python reference for the Ontological Match Score (oms_reference.py), computing direction, distance, and triad-integrity losses against the sequestered ULM graph. - Semantic Logic Mapping (SLM) Specification — formal parser spec (PARSER_SPEC.md), relation inventory, worked examples, failure taxonomy, and JSON Schema (slm.schema.json). - ULM-Bench Benchmark Specification — three task families (Static Retrieval, Cross-Domain Normative Dilemmas, Ontological Rupture), item schema, four conditions (Ungrounded, BFO/CCO, GraphRAG, ULM), six controls, and eight primary endpoints. - Preregistered Confirmatory Protocol — \$25k study design with hypotheses (H-01–H-19), power analysis (N=194/condition for 10pp effect), go/no-go gates (Parser F1 ≥ 0.85, κ ≥ 0.67, OMS AUC ≥ 0.80), and falsification criteria. - Pilot Results — 200 items × 4 conditions; L condition 52% OMS pass (0.707 mean), U/B/G 100% abstain. - Audit Scripts — ulm_audit.py (14,940 checks, 0 errors), build_ulm.py (deterministic builder). - Gold Sets & Annotation Manual — 50-sentence gold set with adjudicated SLMs (κ = 0.82), coding manual.License: Sublation License v4.0 (this record). The preprint is licensed separately under arXiv's terms.Status: Proposal and preregistration. No confirmatory experiments have been run. All artifacts are released for independent verification and execution. ------------------------------------------------------------ Status: Proposal and preregistration. Simulations have been run. No confirmatory experiments have been run. All artifacts released for independent verification and execution under the Sublation License v4.0. Citation: McCormack, M.J.J. (2026). ULM-Bench: A Preregistered Benchmark and Audit Protocol for Ontological Coherence in Language Models. Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23324479 Keywords: language model evaluation, ontological coherence, benchmark, preregistration, Hegel, dialectical logic, AI safety, deception detection, semantic parsing, Anthropic, Safety By Design, Safety-By-Design, BFO, Basic Formal Ontology, gBFO, Genuine Basic Formal Ontology, AI Alignment, ASI Alignment, Super Intelligence, Artificial Super Intelligence, AI Priors, Aristotle, Plato,

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
University of Alberta (CA)
Topic Modeling
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon