Evaluating Decision Criteria for Rooftop Rainwater Harvesting Retrofits in Institutional Buildings: A Critical Integrative Review
Rooftop rainwater harvesting retrofits in institutional buildings require evidence on water performance, affordability, constraints, and operations, yet inconsistent boundaries limit transferability. This critical integrative review examines the decision criteria and evidentiary requirements supporting institutional retrofit decisions. A purposive sample of 83 full-text publications, screened from 309 Web of Science records, was systematically evaluated against 24 predefined criteria spanning financial, environmental, technological, structural, innovation, and social dimensions. Following a targeted verification audit across 1,992 publication–criterion pairs, the resulting evidence matrix documented 205 direct and 402 indirect construct correspondences. Financial and maintenance-related criteria received substantially broader coverage than thermal, structural, and innovation criteria. Direct correspondence spanned diverse forms of support from conceptual inclusion and design assumptions to modelled and measured outcomes. Financial recovery depended heavily on expenditure boundaries and tariff assumptions, while long-term runoff retention and event-scale discharge control represented non-interchangeable hydrological outcomes. A proposed decision architecture separates building context and mandatory eligibility screening from stakeholder preferences and alternative-specific performance, establishing baseline information requirements prior to retrofit comparison. By distinguishing evidentiary depth and exposing overlapping measures, the review establishes a transparent foundation for criterion selection. Although purposive sampling, single-researcher appraisal, and heterogeneous evidence limit generalizability, the prospective framework offers a rigorous basis for future building-specific validation.
Authors
- Pau Chung Leng (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2720-9077)
- Ihab Hasan Hatif (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3591-8324)
- Jie Zhang
Institutions
- Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University (IQ)
- University of Technology Malaysia (MY)
Publication Details
- Journal
- International Journal of Management Thinking
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.56868/ijmt.v4i2.120
- Primary Topic
- Urban Stormwater Management Solutions
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00