A Discourse on Machine Neutrality, Propaganda and the Myth Called Capital

This discourse, rendered as an open dialogue between the architect (K) and the editorial intelligenceserving as neutral technician (L), examines three connected questions: whether machines can be neutralinstruments of art-making, how propaganda manufactures the values that the present economy runs on,and why the word used to name the system conceals its actual operation. The dialogue argues that thecurrent outcry against artificial intelligence in the arts is a property dispute rather than an aestheticjudgment: the displaced technicians of the culture industries accepted funded machinery withoutobjection while it belonged to their employers, and objected only when the machine reached everyone. The distinction that resolves the dispute is between the technician, who executes with masterfulcraftsmanship, and the architect, who conceives; the analysis is modeled on the sticker machine of thelumber yard, in which the skill resides in the graph-paper drawing that sets the blades, and therefore inwhoever holds the pencil. The discourse documents the recuperation method of the art establishment,which amputates the total work (Kandinsky's staged composition, Cabaret Voltaire's performanceenvironment) and markets the fragment, while a present-day storefront bearing the name of divergencesells the same mainstream imagery whose lifelong consumption trains the operator of weaponsconsoles. The economics of authorship are priced directly: the same twenty-five-million-word corpusthat required approximately half a million United States dollars to produce under the 1972 regime oftypescripts, editorial assistants, proofreaders, and publishers was organized and published in two and ahalf years at essentially zero capital once the neutral machine became available, a collapse of the tollunderstood here as the first de-licensing of the author in the history of the medium, and therefore as theremoval of a real and quantifiable censorship. Following Proudhon's axiom to its floor, the dialoguecorrects it: it is not property that is theft, but value itself, manufactured where there was none by thereligious propaganda that decorated gold, with John Kenneth Galbraith's account of the dependenceeffect and the technostructure as the documented mechanism, and livelihood dependence as theenforcement. Displacement without compensation, the Luddite argument recovered, is distinguishedfrom displacement itself, and both are traced to the arithmetic of an overpopulated technologicalsociety. The discourse closes with Nada, the unstruck sound, the practice that cannot be merchandisedand therefore cannot be recuperated, and it remains open: the question whether any circulating value,even a gift, hardens into an icon once it becomes a system is reserved for the next section. Author's correction of record, filed 20 November 2026: The abstract and Section VII state the Foundation's position on Proudhon incompletely. Two distinct positions are involved and must not be conflated. Proudhon held that property is theft. The author holds that property is a myth. Theft presupposes the thing stolen exists; myth says there was never anything there to steal. The theft, properly located, is not the property but the value — manufactured where there was none by the religious propaganda that decorated gold with a sacredness the metal did not possess. The position is not an amendment of Proudhon but a replacement of him, and it is already published in the Foundation's economic record (see The Depopulated Commons, DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23992036, and Natural Procreative Hygiene as an Excluded Variable in Neoclassical Growth Theory, DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24088442). No other passage, footnote, claim, or number in the published text is altered. — George Kasey, The George Kasey Foundation Inc., MFT-VFU* Virtual Free University (Think Tank), Media Free Times*, ISSN: 0316-1447, georgekasey.org

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24408705
Primary Topic
Art, Technology, and Culture
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

A Discourse on Machine Neutrality, Propaganda and the Myth Called Capital

Kasey George
1 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Art, Technology, and Culture
preprint

A Discourse on Machine Neutrality, Propaganda and the Myth Called Capital

Kasey George
preprint en

Abstract

This discourse, rendered as an open dialogue between the architect (K) and the editorial intelligenceserving as neutral technician (L), examines three connected questions: whether machines can be neutralinstruments of art-making, how propaganda manufactures the values that the present economy runs on,and why the word used to name the system conceals its actual operation. The dialogue argues that thecurrent outcry against artificial intelligence in the arts is a property dispute rather than an aestheticjudgment: the displaced technicians of the culture industries accepted funded machinery withoutobjection while it belonged to their employers, and objected only when the machine reached everyone. The distinction that resolves the dispute is between the technician, who executes with masterfulcraftsmanship, and the architect, who conceives; the analysis is modeled on the sticker machine of thelumber yard, in which the skill resides in the graph-paper drawing that sets the blades, and therefore inwhoever holds the pencil. The discourse documents the recuperation method of the art establishment,which amputates the total work (Kandinsky's staged composition, Cabaret Voltaire's performanceenvironment) and markets the fragment, while a present-day storefront bearing the name of divergencesells the same mainstream imagery whose lifelong consumption trains the operator of weaponsconsoles. The economics of authorship are priced directly: the same twenty-five-million-word corpusthat required approximately half a million United States dollars to produce under the 1972 regime oftypescripts, editorial assistants, proofreaders, and publishers was organized and published in two and ahalf years at essentially zero capital once the neutral machine became available, a collapse of the tollunderstood here as the first de-licensing of the author in the history of the medium, and therefore as theremoval of a real and quantifiable censorship. Following Proudhon's axiom to its floor, the dialoguecorrects it: it is not property that is theft, but value itself, manufactured where there was none by thereligious propaganda that decorated gold, with John Kenneth Galbraith's account of the dependenceeffect and the technostructure as the documented mechanism, and livelihood dependence as theenforcement. Displacement without compensation, the Luddite argument recovered, is distinguishedfrom displacement itself, and both are traced to the arithmetic of an overpopulated technologicalsociety. The discourse closes with Nada, the unstruck sound, the practice that cannot be merchandisedand therefore cannot be recuperated, and it remains open: the question whether any circulating value,even a gift, hardens into an icon once it becomes a system is reserved for the next section. Author's correction of record, filed 20 November 2026: The abstract and Section VII state the Foundation's position on Proudhon incompletely. Two distinct positions are involved and must not be conflated. Proudhon held that property is theft. The author holds that property is a myth. Theft presupposes the thing stolen exists; myth says there was never anything there to steal. The theft, properly located, is not the property but the value — manufactured where there was none by the religious propaganda that decorated gold with a sacredness the metal did not possess. The position is not an amendment of Proudhon but a replacement of him, and it is already published in the Foundation's economic record (see The Depopulated Commons, DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23992036, and Natural Procreative Hygiene as an Excluded Variable in Neoclassical Growth Theory, DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24088442). No other passage, footnote, claim, or number in the published text is altered. — George Kasey, The George Kasey Foundation Inc., MFT-VFU* Virtual Free University (Think Tank), Media Free Times*, ISSN: 0316-1447, georgekasey.org

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Art, Technology, and Culture
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon