A Taxonomy of Epistemic and Normative Challenges in Juridical Processes Within Nonlinear Dynamical Systems
This conceptual inquiry examines how difficulties associated with historically generated, nonlinear relational systems bear differently on the activities of juridical institutions and on judgments concerning justice. It first distinguishes seven interconnected problems: critical transitions, historical dependence, distributed causation, partial observability, situated interpretation, reflexive intervention, and irreversibility. These properties are not treated as independent defects of law. Their juridical significance is examined through five provisional functional families: the constitution of relationships and legal powers; regulation and coordination; protection and prevention; adjudication and remediation; and accountability and normative transformation. A qualitative $7 \times 5$ matrix considers the mechanisms that may obstruct each function, established forms of institutional response, and residual questions that cannot be resolved simply by reconstructing more evidence. The inquiry then examines how structural position and unequal access to resources condition participation, and how interpretive sequences may influence the evaluation of shared evidence. Selected hypothetical cases and small dynamical and operator-based models illustrate mechanisms; they are not presented as empirical estimates or measures of justice. The final philosophical analysis distinguishes ontological, relational, and manifestational reality in Generative-Relational (GR) thought, while considering the aesthetic recognition, institutional authority, and normative justification of justice. An extended treatment of irreversibility explores why reversal of a legal act need not restore lost opportunities, and why protective timing may matter without automatically authorizing coercion. The paper neither assumes that complete knowledge of external social dynamics is required for justified juridical action nor identifies functional continuity with justice. It instead offers a comparative framework for examining how juridical functions may remain available, interact, or conflict under complexity, together with a restrained commentary on the costly and historically situated pursuit of justice.
Authors
- Wanhong HUANG
Publication Details
- Journal
- Knowledge Commons Works (Michigan State University)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.17613/ymm05-3ar17
- Primary Topic
- Legal and Social Philosophy
- Type
- preprint