Evaluating the teleonome as a biologically grounded process for welfare assessment and monitoring that operationalises animal agency

Assessing the welfare of sentient animals, where sufficient species-specific knowledge is available, depends on inferring subjective experience from observable proxies of bio-regulatory function. However, the interpretative logic that connects indicators to experience can now be extended by including fresh perspectives based on recently developed teleonomic reasoning. The teleonome is the integrated biological system through which organisms pursue survival and reproductively critical goals. Drawing on evolutionary biology, bio-regulatory physiology, ethology, and affective neuroscience, this article proposes a four-stage welfare assessment process: i.e., mapping active bio-regulatory cycles (Stage 1); auditing the teleonomic affordances (opportunities and resources) available to support resolution of active bio-regulatory cycles (Stage 2); estimating allostatic load (functional costs) and the potential to resist perturbations (Stage 3); and inferring the affective trajectory (Stage 4). The outputs of Stages 2, 3 and 4 are the components of teleonomic agency, which incorporate the following three features: the fit between available physical and social opportunities and the animal’s current regulatory needs; the bio-regulatory reserves available to meet the functional costs of engaging in directed responses; and the animal’s expectation that apposite engagement can change outcomes. When animals present with similar welfare indicators, distinguishing these three components clarifies which of them is limiting for a given animal, thereby guiding what specific interventions should address. Throughout, teleonomic reasoning functions as a framework for interpreting what each indicator of the bio-regulatory process reflects, what it implies for affective experience, and what it predicts about the likely direction of welfare if current conditions were to persist. This approach anchors welfare assessment to the biology of individuals, scaled from species-typical bio-regulatory architecture to the specific animal at a particular life stage and under particular conditions. Because several bio-regulatory systems may be on different trajectories simultaneously, the framework supports triage, i.e., prioritising intervention by steepness of decline and reversibility of the driving conditions. Each stage is mapped onto the 2020 Five Domains Model, showing where teleonomic reasoning supplies the inferential step between an observable indicator and an inference about subjective experience. It is intended to complement existing welfare assessment methodologies in otherwise well-researched sentient animals.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Frontiers in Animal Science
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fanim.2026.1916735
Primary Topic
Animal Behavior and Welfare Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Evaluating the teleonome as a biologically grounded process for welfare assessment and monitoring that operationalises animal agency

Amy Dianne Lykins, David John Mellor, Cristina L. Wilkins, Cathrynne Henshall et al.
3 links
Frontiers in Animal Science
Animal Behavior and Welfare Studies
article

Evaluating the teleonome as a biologically grounded process for welfare assessment and monitoring that operationalises animal agency

Amy Dianne Lykins, David John Mellor, Cristina L. Wilkins, Cathrynne Henshall, Paul Damien McGreevy, Melanie Fillios
article en

Abstract

Assessing the welfare of sentient animals, where sufficient species-specific knowledge is available, depends on inferring subjective experience from observable proxies of bio-regulatory function. However, the interpretative logic that connects indicators to experience can now be extended by including fresh perspectives based on recently developed teleonomic reasoning. The teleonome is the integrated biological system through which organisms pursue survival and reproductively critical goals. Drawing on evolutionary biology, bio-regulatory physiology, ethology, and affective neuroscience, this article proposes a four-stage welfare assessment process: i.e., mapping active bio-regulatory cycles (Stage 1); auditing the teleonomic affordances (opportunities and resources) available to support resolution of active bio-regulatory cycles (Stage 2); estimating allostatic load (functional costs) and the potential to resist perturbations (Stage 3); and inferring the affective trajectory (Stage 4). The outputs of Stages 2, 3 and 4 are the components of teleonomic agency, which incorporate the following three features: the fit between available physical and social opportunities and the animal’s current regulatory needs; the bio-regulatory reserves available to meet the functional costs of engaging in directed responses; and the animal’s expectation that apposite engagement can change outcomes. When animals present with similar welfare indicators, distinguishing these three components clarifies which of them is limiting for a given animal, thereby guiding what specific interventions should address. Throughout, teleonomic reasoning functions as a framework for interpreting what each indicator of the bio-regulatory process reflects, what it implies for affective experience, and what it predicts about the likely direction of welfare if current conditions were to persist. This approach anchors welfare assessment to the biology of individuals, scaled from species-typical bio-regulatory architecture to the specific animal at a particular life stage and under particular conditions. Because several bio-regulatory systems may be on different trajectories simultaneously, the framework supports triage, i.e., prioritising intervention by steepness of decline and reversibility of the driving conditions. Each stage is mapped onto the 2020 Five Domains Model, showing where teleonomic reasoning supplies the inferential step between an observable indicator and an inference about subjective experience. It is intended to complement existing welfare assessment methodologies in otherwise well-researched sentient animals.

Frontiers in Animal ScienceVol. 7
The University of Sydney (AU), Charles Sturt University (AU), Massey University (NZ), Southern Cross University (AU), University of New England (AU)
Australian Government
Animal Behavior and Welfare Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon