One size does not fit all: a comparative framework for coastal habitat resilience and sensitivity under environmental disturbance

Coastal habitats provide ecosystem services that support shoreline protection, biodiversity, and human well-being, yet they are increasingly exposed to climate-driven and anthropogenic disturbances. Although ecosystem-based adaptation and nature-based solutions are increasingly incorporated into coastal management, coastal habitats differ substantially in their ecological function, geomorphology, and responses to disturbance, challenging the notion of uniform adaptation approaches. This review presents a comparative narrative synthesis of intertidal and subtidal coastal habitats, examining disturbance-specific resilience, sensitivity, recovery, and vulnerability across physical disturbances, sediment change and erosion, heatwaves and temperature stress, pollution and water quality, biological disturbances, and long-term pressures associated with sea level rise and climate change. The synthesis demonstrates that resilience arises through different ecological and geomorphological mechanisms rather than from a single characteristic of the habitat type. This review highlights substantial uncertainty in long-term recovery trajectories and adaptive capacity, particularly where habitats are exposed to cumulative chronic stressors. An illustrative resilience, sensitivity, and vulnerability framework is developed to support comparative assessment; however, the resulting scores are qualitative, evidence-informed, and context-dependent rather than universal or location-independent habitat rankings. By integrating resilience, sensitivity, vulnerability, and the mechanisms that constrain recovery, this study highlights the importance of habitat-specific, process-based, context-dependent adaptation strategies. The framework provides a basis for guiding coastal management decisions and adaptation planning that incorporates local geomorphological and ecological conditions while recognising the heterogeneity and uncertainty of coastal habitat response, all while enhancing long-term stability and reducing vulnerability of these important ecosystems.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Regional Environmental Change
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-026-02730-8
Primary Topic
Coastal wetland ecosystem dynamics
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

One size does not fit all: a comparative framework for coastal habitat resilience and sensitivity under environmental disturbance

Erica Terese Krueger
2 links
Regional Environmental Change
Coastal wetland ecosystem dynamics
article

One size does not fit all: a comparative framework for coastal habitat resilience and sensitivity under environmental disturbance

Erica Terese Krueger
article en

Abstract

Coastal habitats provide ecosystem services that support shoreline protection, biodiversity, and human well-being, yet they are increasingly exposed to climate-driven and anthropogenic disturbances. Although ecosystem-based adaptation and nature-based solutions are increasingly incorporated into coastal management, coastal habitats differ substantially in their ecological function, geomorphology, and responses to disturbance, challenging the notion of uniform adaptation approaches. This review presents a comparative narrative synthesis of intertidal and subtidal coastal habitats, examining disturbance-specific resilience, sensitivity, recovery, and vulnerability across physical disturbances, sediment change and erosion, heatwaves and temperature stress, pollution and water quality, biological disturbances, and long-term pressures associated with sea level rise and climate change. The synthesis demonstrates that resilience arises through different ecological and geomorphological mechanisms rather than from a single characteristic of the habitat type. This review highlights substantial uncertainty in long-term recovery trajectories and adaptive capacity, particularly where habitats are exposed to cumulative chronic stressors. An illustrative resilience, sensitivity, and vulnerability framework is developed to support comparative assessment; however, the resulting scores are qualitative, evidence-informed, and context-dependent rather than universal or location-independent habitat rankings. By integrating resilience, sensitivity, vulnerability, and the mechanisms that constrain recovery, this study highlights the importance of habitat-specific, process-based, context-dependent adaptation strategies. The framework provides a basis for guiding coastal management decisions and adaptation planning that incorporates local geomorphological and ecological conditions while recognising the heterogeneity and uncertainty of coastal habitat response, all while enhancing long-term stability and reducing vulnerability of these important ecosystems.

Regional Environmental ChangeVol. 26(4)
Climate action, Life on land
Coastal wetland ecosystem dynamics
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon
One size does not fit all: a comparative framework for coastal habitat resilience and sensitivity under environmental disturbance — Erica Terese Krueger · Regional Environmental Change (2026) | TGRS Research Map | TGRS