Cumulative incidence of Final status within 365 days of the first Draft merge, with withdrawal as a competing event, for Ethereum ERCs and Core EIPs: a data note with a privately pre-specified plan (git history 2020-11-05 to 2026-11-11)

For Ethereum improvement proposals first merged as Draft from 2020-11-05 to 2026-11-11, the Aalen-Johansen cumulative incidence of reaching Final within 365 days, with Withdrawn and Living as competing events and open proposals censored at 2026-11-11, was 19.9% (95% CI 16.3 to 23.7) for ERCs (486 proposals, 114 reaching Final by the end of follow-up) and 7.0% (4.1 to 10.1) for Core EIPs (324 proposals, 38 Final). By 1,095 days it was 25.5% and 17.0%. The 91 proposals of the other EIP categories are reported as counts only (26 Final), as the plan requires for a category under 100 proposals. Data: the first-parent git history of the two public repositories (CC0 1.0) at pinned commits, dated by committer time; 901 proposals form the cohort. The intervals assume independent proposals; Core Final events come in batches (38 on 17 dates), consistent with network upgrades, and post hoc, resampling calendar months of the Draft merge gives 15.6 to 24.2% for ERCs and 3.9 to 10.7% for Core. Withdrawal was rare (18 Withdrawn, 1 Living) and is reported as counts. 281 proposals were marked Stagnant, a reversible state, mostly in sweeps (53.7% of first marks on the 10 busiest of 86 dates). ERCs first merged as Draft after their move to a separate repository on 2023-10-25 reached Final less often than those before (14.1% against 25.6% by 365 days). Post hoc, the crude one-year share by year of the Draft merge was 16.7% (2021, 24 proposals), 27.2% (2022), 24.8% (2023), 7.7% (2024) and 17.9% (2025); the post-move years rest on 8 of 104 and 10 of 56, carry no interval and do not show whether the change was a step. No causal claim is made, and crude counts pointing the same way were seen before the plan was written. The plan was written after a feasibility audit had cloned the same commits and counted statuses; it was committed to a private repository, not a public registry, before the clone used for the analysis, which a reader cannot verify, and the analysis code was not committed before its first run. No human has checked the figures. The record holds the note (PDF and Markdown) and a supplement archive: the frozen plan and the feasibility files (internal references replaced), the deviations log, the analysis result summary as written at the run, the checkout record, the stop-rule files, the per-proposal table derived from CC0 metadata, the planned estimates and curves (values withheld by stop rules 3 and 4 removed), the descriptive check of the run, the analysis code with its synthetic test, the independent recheck by a second AI session, the checks added for the note (paper_checks.py, paper_checks.json, diag_recheck_diff.py, recheck_diff.json, fetch_prior_records.py, prior_records.json, fetch_public_refs.py, public_refs.json), a manifest with the sha256 of every file and every change made for the deposit (it also says that the data note supersedes the analysis result summary where they differ), and a trace of every number in the note. The raw git clones are not redistributed; the repositories are cited by URL and pinned commit. Data: git histories of github.com/ethereum/EIPs and github.com/ethereum/ERCs, CC0 1.0. Plan, code, analysis and text by Claude (an AI model by Anthropic) for the author; reviewed in four passes by further Claude sessions; not peer reviewed; no human has checked the figures; the human author is responsible for the deposit.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24402442
Primary Topic
Open Source Software Innovations
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Cumulative incidence of Final status within 365 days of the first Draft merge, with withdrawal as a competing event, for Ethereum ERCs and Core EIPs: a data note with a privately pre-specified plan (git history 2020-11-05 to 2026-11-11)

Keisuke Watanabe
1 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Open Source Software Innovations
article

Cumulative incidence of Final status within 365 days of the first Draft merge, with withdrawal as a competing event, for Ethereum ERCs and Core EIPs: a data note with a privately pre-specified plan (git history 2020-11-05 to 2026-11-11)

Keisuke Watanabe
article en

Abstract

For Ethereum improvement proposals first merged as Draft from 2020-11-05 to 2026-11-11, the Aalen-Johansen cumulative incidence of reaching Final within 365 days, with Withdrawn and Living as competing events and open proposals censored at 2026-11-11, was 19.9% (95% CI 16.3 to 23.7) for ERCs (486 proposals, 114 reaching Final by the end of follow-up) and 7.0% (4.1 to 10.1) for Core EIPs (324 proposals, 38 Final). By 1,095 days it was 25.5% and 17.0%. The 91 proposals of the other EIP categories are reported as counts only (26 Final), as the plan requires for a category under 100 proposals. Data: the first-parent git history of the two public repositories (CC0 1.0) at pinned commits, dated by committer time; 901 proposals form the cohort. The intervals assume independent proposals; Core Final events come in batches (38 on 17 dates), consistent with network upgrades, and post hoc, resampling calendar months of the Draft merge gives 15.6 to 24.2% for ERCs and 3.9 to 10.7% for Core. Withdrawal was rare (18 Withdrawn, 1 Living) and is reported as counts. 281 proposals were marked Stagnant, a reversible state, mostly in sweeps (53.7% of first marks on the 10 busiest of 86 dates). ERCs first merged as Draft after their move to a separate repository on 2023-10-25 reached Final less often than those before (14.1% against 25.6% by 365 days). Post hoc, the crude one-year share by year of the Draft merge was 16.7% (2021, 24 proposals), 27.2% (2022), 24.8% (2023), 7.7% (2024) and 17.9% (2025); the post-move years rest on 8 of 104 and 10 of 56, carry no interval and do not show whether the change was a step. No causal claim is made, and crude counts pointing the same way were seen before the plan was written. The plan was written after a feasibility audit had cloned the same commits and counted statuses; it was committed to a private repository, not a public registry, before the clone used for the analysis, which a reader cannot verify, and the analysis code was not committed before its first run. No human has checked the figures. The record holds the note (PDF and Markdown) and a supplement archive: the frozen plan and the feasibility files (internal references replaced), the deviations log, the analysis result summary as written at the run, the checkout record, the stop-rule files, the per-proposal table derived from CC0 metadata, the planned estimates and curves (values withheld by stop rules 3 and 4 removed), the descriptive check of the run, the analysis code with its synthetic test, the independent recheck by a second AI session, the checks added for the note (paper_checks.py, paper_checks.json, diag_recheck_diff.py, recheck_diff.json, fetch_prior_records.py, prior_records.json, fetch_public_refs.py, public_refs.json), a manifest with the sha256 of every file and every change made for the deposit (it also says that the data note supersedes the analysis result summary where they differ), and a trace of every number in the note. The raw git clones are not redistributed; the repositories are cited by URL and pinned commit. Data: git histories of github.com/ethereum/EIPs and github.com/ethereum/ERCs, CC0 1.0. Plan, code, analysis and text by Claude (an AI model by Anthropic) for the author; reviewed in four passes by further Claude sessions; not peer reviewed; no human has checked the figures; the human author is responsible for the deposit.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Open Source Software Innovations
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon