Construction and empirical test of an evaluation system for the high-quality development of national fitness facilities in Hunan Province

Background Public fitness facilities shape opportunities for physical activity, yet evaluations of national fitness facilities in China have emphasized quantity over quality and often use poorly defined dimensions. This study developed and empirically tested a multidimensional evaluation system for the high-quality development of national fitness facilities in Hunan Province. Methods Candidate indicators derived from policy documents, facility standards, and the literature were screened in a two-round Delphi consultation with 15 experts using retention criteria (mean importance > 3.5 and coefficient of variation < 0.25), resulting in an indicator system based on the five development concepts of innovation, coordination, green development, openness, and sharing. Indicator weights were derived with the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) from geometric-mean group judgment matrices. Current performance was assessed by two-level fuzzy comprehensive evaluation (FCE) using 475 valid questionnaires from managers and residents in 10 cities and prefectures. Sensitivity analyses of weights (228 scenarios) and grade thresholds, along with bootstrap resampling (2,000 resamples), tested robustness. Results The final system comprised 5 first-level and 33 second-level indicators, and all AHP judgment matrices had CR < 0.10 (criterion level: CR = 0.0422). Exploratory factor analysis yielded a five-factor structure consistent with the proposed dimensions. The comprehensive evaluation vector was (0.2280, 0.3752, 0.2683, 0.1027, 0.0258), yielding an overall score of 3.6768 (95% bootstrap CI: 3.624–3.726) and a good grade. Dimension scores were 3.8085 for coordination, 3.7821 for innovation, 3.6538 for openness, 3.5278 for green development, and 3.5025 for sharing. For green development and sharing, the confidence intervals spanned the boundary between the good and moderate grades. The overall grade was unchanged in all weight scenarios but changed when the grade boundaries were increased by 0.25. Conclusion Per capita venue area, water consumption, and the opening of public and school venues were above average in importance but below average in performance and should be prioritized for verification and improvement. The framework separates expert-defined importance from stakeholder-perceived performance and documents each computational step, so that it can be checked and re-applied. Because scores reflect stakeholder perceptions in a non-probability sample, they should be validated against administrative and facility-level data before being used to allocate resources.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Frontiers in Public Health
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2026.1970856
Primary Topic
Evaluation Methods in Various Fields
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Construction and empirical test of an evaluation system for the high-quality development of national fitness facilities in Hunan Province

Lijun Zhou, Zhangpin Hu, Liyuan Yuan, Yute Pan
1 links
Frontiers in Public Health
Evaluation Methods in Various Fields
article

Construction and empirical test of an evaluation system for the high-quality development of national fitness facilities in Hunan Province

Lijun Zhou, Zhangpin Hu, Liyuan Yuan, Yute Pan
article en

Abstract

Background Public fitness facilities shape opportunities for physical activity, yet evaluations of national fitness facilities in China have emphasized quantity over quality and often use poorly defined dimensions. This study developed and empirically tested a multidimensional evaluation system for the high-quality development of national fitness facilities in Hunan Province. Methods Candidate indicators derived from policy documents, facility standards, and the literature were screened in a two-round Delphi consultation with 15 experts using retention criteria (mean importance > 3.5 and coefficient of variation < 0.25), resulting in an indicator system based on the five development concepts of innovation, coordination, green development, openness, and sharing. Indicator weights were derived with the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) from geometric-mean group judgment matrices. Current performance was assessed by two-level fuzzy comprehensive evaluation (FCE) using 475 valid questionnaires from managers and residents in 10 cities and prefectures. Sensitivity analyses of weights (228 scenarios) and grade thresholds, along with bootstrap resampling (2,000 resamples), tested robustness. Results The final system comprised 5 first-level and 33 second-level indicators, and all AHP judgment matrices had CR < 0.10 (criterion level: CR = 0.0422). Exploratory factor analysis yielded a five-factor structure consistent with the proposed dimensions. The comprehensive evaluation vector was (0.2280, 0.3752, 0.2683, 0.1027, 0.0258), yielding an overall score of 3.6768 (95% bootstrap CI: 3.624–3.726) and a good grade. Dimension scores were 3.8085 for coordination, 3.7821 for innovation, 3.6538 for openness, 3.5278 for green development, and 3.5025 for sharing. For green development and sharing, the confidence intervals spanned the boundary between the good and moderate grades. The overall grade was unchanged in all weight scenarios but changed when the grade boundaries were increased by 0.25. Conclusion Per capita venue area, water consumption, and the opening of public and school venues were above average in importance but below average in performance and should be prioritized for verification and improvement. The framework separates expert-defined importance from stakeholder-perceived performance and documents each computational step, so that it can be checked and re-applied. Because scores reflect stakeholder perceptions in a non-probability sample, they should be validated against administrative and facility-level data before being used to allocate resources.

Frontiers in Public HealthVol. 14
Fujian Normal University (CN), Guangxi Minzu University (CN), Yongzhou Vocational Technical College (CN)
Good health and well-being
Evaluation Methods in Various Fields
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon