Brand Loyalty as Cognitive Cost Optimization: Income, Search Frictions, and AI-Assisted Brand Switching
A buyer who returns to a familiar brand may be saving the work of evaluating a substitute. How much of that loyalty survives when a comparison becomes cheap? This paper separates two decisions: whether to investigate a rival and whether to switch after learning what it offers. Familiarity can save search and verification effort. Brand-specific skills, genuine preference and contractual costs can still favor the incumbent after a buyer sees the evidence. Income affects both the value of time and the cost of a purchasing mistake, so the predicted direction varies with the household and product. A hypothetical electric-vehicle comparison illustrates the distinction. Under the stated assumptions, verified information is worth CAD 270 before search costs, even though it leads to switching in only 30% of cases. A proposed four-arm experiment compares ordinary search, a structured table, a source-linked AI assistant and an assistant with commercially biased ordering. Its primary outcomes are choice consistent with the buyer’s prior preferences and switching when a challenger offers a verified net advantage. The paper develops six hypotheses and reports no original participant data.
Authors
- Tina Qiaotian Yan
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24403038
- Primary Topic
- Consumer Market Behavior and Pricing
- Type
- preprint