Securing Collaborative Data Ecosystems: A Sociotechnical Framework for Mitigating Insider Risk and Governance Fail-ures in Inter Organizational Information Systems

The use of inter-organizational information systems (such as cloud computing environments, data markets and sup-ply chains) provides organizations with the ability to manage their activities together and generate value from those shared activities. However, while technical controls are important to limit the spread of damage caused by unauthor-ized actions taken by employees within the organization, technical controls cannot prevent the consequences of em-ployees acting outside of established policies or the absence of effective organizational governance. A single over-permissive policy or configuration error can affect multiple organizations that are part of the same network and lead to loss of trust among those organizations and non-compliance with regulations. To address the need for a compre-hensive sociotechnical framework for understanding how behavior, technical controls and institutional governance influence the exposure of organizations to risk, we developed the Collaborative Security Alignment (CSA) model based upon Orlikowski's duality of technology, Protection Motivation Theory and Task-Technology Fit. The CSA model proposes that: (a) Technical controls are a prerequisite for protecting organization resources but are not suffi-cient; (b) Organizational culture and behavioral nudges influence the effectiveness of technical controls; and (c) Inter-organizational governance (via contracts, auditing and common metrics) contributes to long-term resiliency. We used a convergent mixed methods approach to assess the validity of the CSA model. We conducted a survey of 210 IS professionals and analyzed the data using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM); we completed three case studies and analyzed them using thematic analysis; and we created a novel, reproducible simulation that compares a rule-based baseline to a CSA toolkit consisting of machine learning-based anomaly detection, workflow-embedded policy nudges, tiered access governance, and shared auditing. Our SEM analysis supported each of our four hypoth-eses. Our simulation results indicated that when all components of the CSA toolkit were applied collectively, the aggregate exposure to vulnerabilities was reduced by approximately 67 percent compared to the baseline (range of sectors was 56-80%). Since the reduction in exposure to vulnerability is dependent on the assumptions made con-cerning the effects of each component of the CSA toolkit, we provide ablation and sensitivity analyses (results var-ied from 58-75 percent across the tested ranges) and consider the findings as a demonstration of the model's capabil-ities as opposed to empirical evidence. We conclude our paper with recommendations for managers and discussions of algorithmic fairness, ethical considerations related to conducting research and cross-jurisdictional regulatory compliance issues.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Muthanna Journal of Engineering and Technology
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.52113/3/eng/mjet/2026-14-04-/347-359
Primary Topic
Information and Cyber Security
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Securing Collaborative Data Ecosystems: A Sociotechnical Framework for Mitigating Insider Risk and Governance Fail-ures in Inter Organizational Information Systems

Barakat Saad Ibrahim
Muthanna Journal of Engineering and Technology
Information and Cyber Security
article

Securing Collaborative Data Ecosystems: A Sociotechnical Framework for Mitigating Insider Risk and Governance Fail-ures in Inter Organizational Information Systems

Barakat Saad Ibrahim
article en

Abstract

The use of inter-organizational information systems (such as cloud computing environments, data markets and sup-ply chains) provides organizations with the ability to manage their activities together and generate value from those shared activities. However, while technical controls are important to limit the spread of damage caused by unauthor-ized actions taken by employees within the organization, technical controls cannot prevent the consequences of em-ployees acting outside of established policies or the absence of effective organizational governance. A single over-permissive policy or configuration error can affect multiple organizations that are part of the same network and lead to loss of trust among those organizations and non-compliance with regulations. To address the need for a compre-hensive sociotechnical framework for understanding how behavior, technical controls and institutional governance influence the exposure of organizations to risk, we developed the Collaborative Security Alignment (CSA) model based upon Orlikowski's duality of technology, Protection Motivation Theory and Task-Technology Fit. The CSA model proposes that: (a) Technical controls are a prerequisite for protecting organization resources but are not suffi-cient; (b) Organizational culture and behavioral nudges influence the effectiveness of technical controls; and (c) Inter-organizational governance (via contracts, auditing and common metrics) contributes to long-term resiliency. We used a convergent mixed methods approach to assess the validity of the CSA model. We conducted a survey of 210 IS professionals and analyzed the data using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM); we completed three case studies and analyzed them using thematic analysis; and we created a novel, reproducible simulation that compares a rule-based baseline to a CSA toolkit consisting of machine learning-based anomaly detection, workflow-embedded policy nudges, tiered access governance, and shared auditing. Our SEM analysis supported each of our four hypoth-eses. Our simulation results indicated that when all components of the CSA toolkit were applied collectively, the aggregate exposure to vulnerabilities was reduced by approximately 67 percent compared to the baseline (range of sectors was 56-80%). Since the reduction in exposure to vulnerability is dependent on the assumptions made con-cerning the effects of each component of the CSA toolkit, we provide ablation and sensitivity analyses (results var-ied from 58-75 percent across the tested ranges) and consider the findings as a demonstration of the model's capabil-ities as opposed to empirical evidence. We conclude our paper with recommendations for managers and discussions of algorithmic fairness, ethical considerations related to conducting research and cross-jurisdictional regulatory compliance issues.

Muthanna Journal of Engineering and TechnologyVol. 14(04)
Al-Muthanna University (IQ)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions
Information and Cyber Security
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon