Confronting the supercritical-field literature: what internal BW shares with the supercritical vacuum, where it differs by sign, and the eight rectifications of this analysis

This paper confronts the internal Breit–Wheeler (BW) mechanism of the Conjugate Photonic Model (MFC/CPM) with the supercritical electromagnetic field literature (Greiner, Rafelski, Shabaev, and the ORANGE/EPOS collaborations at GSI Darmstadt), previously absent from the corpus. To prevent circularity (criterion C5), the study strictly separates apparatus measurements — continuous positron spectra in heavy-ion collisions near the Coulomb barrier ($Z_u = 164$ to $184$, for Pb+Pb, U+Ta, and U+U), following a single unbroken power law with an empirical normalization factor of $\approx 0.75$ relative to coupled-channel calculations and the exclusion of narrow spontaneous lines — from unobserved theoretical calculations ($Z_{\rm cr} \approx 171.5$, the dressed nucleus, and electron retention in the negative-energy continuum). The comparison shows that whereas the supercritical framework leaves the nuclear charge $Z$ unchanged and selects the electron via parity-even Coulomb attraction, the MFC retains the positron through internal topological fibration chirality (id 42), establishing novelty without external support alongside symmetry of empirical standing, since spontaneous positron emission has never been observed. Executing falsifier F92 demonstrates that the id 445 field criterion ($\rho_E \ge E_{\rm crit}^2/\varepsilon_0$) is saturated across the entire barrier curve ($E/E_{\rm crit}$ from $356.3$ to $378.8$), passing in structure by predicting no break, but failing in value by not deriving the $10^{-6}$ yield or its $9.4\times$ growth; however, auditing the experimental design reveals degeneracy along the barrier family (velocity frozen within $2.5\%$ and only three named collision systems, with a single point above $171.5$), weakening the test's resolving power. The article introduces falsifiers F89–F91 (withdrawing F88 under C5), contrasts the zero-tolerance discrete counting rule $N_{\rm BW}$ (11/11 exact) against the coverage and nuclear-structure input ($42.9\%$ in $\text{U}^{91+}$) of strong-field Lamb-shift QED, establishes clause C8 (requiring complete tables with hits, deviations, and explicit denominators), and replaces sequential verdicts with a simultaneous sector inventory accompanied by 25 documented self-rectifications of the analysis.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24408512
Primary Topic
Atomic and Molecular Physics
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Confronting the supercritical-field literature: what internal BW shares with the supercritical vacuum, where it differs by sign, and the eight rectifications of this analysis

Rubens Nunes Caputo
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Atomic and Molecular Physics
article

Confronting the supercritical-field literature: what internal BW shares with the supercritical vacuum, where it differs by sign, and the eight rectifications of this analysis

Rubens Nunes Caputo
article en

Abstract

This paper confronts the internal Breit–Wheeler (BW) mechanism of the Conjugate Photonic Model (MFC/CPM) with the supercritical electromagnetic field literature (Greiner, Rafelski, Shabaev, and the ORANGE/EPOS collaborations at GSI Darmstadt), previously absent from the corpus. To prevent circularity (criterion C5), the study strictly separates apparatus measurements — continuous positron spectra in heavy-ion collisions near the Coulomb barrier ($Z_u = 164$ to $184$, for Pb+Pb, U+Ta, and U+U), following a single unbroken power law with an empirical normalization factor of $\approx 0.75$ relative to coupled-channel calculations and the exclusion of narrow spontaneous lines — from unobserved theoretical calculations ($Z_{\rm cr} \approx 171.5$, the dressed nucleus, and electron retention in the negative-energy continuum). The comparison shows that whereas the supercritical framework leaves the nuclear charge $Z$ unchanged and selects the electron via parity-even Coulomb attraction, the MFC retains the positron through internal topological fibration chirality (id 42), establishing novelty without external support alongside symmetry of empirical standing, since spontaneous positron emission has never been observed. Executing falsifier F92 demonstrates that the id 445 field criterion ($\rho_E \ge E_{\rm crit}^2/\varepsilon_0$) is saturated across the entire barrier curve ($E/E_{\rm crit}$ from $356.3$ to $378.8$), passing in structure by predicting no break, but failing in value by not deriving the $10^{-6}$ yield or its $9.4\times$ growth; however, auditing the experimental design reveals degeneracy along the barrier family (velocity frozen within $2.5\%$ and only three named collision systems, with a single point above $171.5$), weakening the test's resolving power. The article introduces falsifiers F89–F91 (withdrawing F88 under C5), contrasts the zero-tolerance discrete counting rule $N_{\rm BW}$ (11/11 exact) against the coverage and nuclear-structure input ($42.9\%$ in $\text{U}^{91+}$) of strong-field Lamb-shift QED, establishes clause C8 (requiring complete tables with hits, deviations, and explicit denominators), and replaces sequential verdicts with a simultaneous sector inventory accompanied by 25 documented self-rectifications of the analysis.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Atomic and Molecular Physics
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon