The effects of the new electoral system on geographic representation in the Baden-Württemberg Landtag
Responding to calls for more replication studies in political science, this research note tests whether an urban bias found for elections to the German Bundestag can also be detected in elections at the state-level. In 2022, Baden-Württemberg replaced its personalized proportional representation system without party lists with a two-vote system similar to the old federal electoral system. This marked the first time that closed, statewide party lists were introduced. Haffert (2024) demonstrated, with regard to federal elections, that this electoral system favors politically fragmented districts, thereby leading to the overrepresentation of urban districts in the Bundestag. This research note replicates Haffert’s analysis for the first election in Baden-Württemberg under the new rules in 2026 using original data at the district and candidate levels. The results show that fragmented districts return more representatives, and that all parties except the CDU allocate better list positions to candidates from their strongholds. However, it is not the constituencies with high population density and university towns that are overrepresented; rather, these constituencies—which are strongly dominated by the Greens—are represented in the state parliament by relatively few representatives. The geographical imbalance in favor of cities identified by Haffert for the federal election should therefore be viewed as an interplay between electoral rules—including the relatively large size of the districts compared to the districts for the Baden-Württemberg state election (which undermines electoral homogeneity)—and the structure of the party system, rather than solely as a consequence of the electoral system itself. More generally, the findings suggest that the geographic consequences of mixed-member systems are contingent on the spatial structure of party support—a lesson relevant to the many democracies in which urban-rural divides are reshaping party competition and fostering polarization.
Authors
- Sebastian Jäckle (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9258-4888)
Institutions
- University of Freiburg (DE)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1007/s12286-026-00666-1
- Primary Topic
- Electoral Systems and Political Participation
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00