The Perceived Presence of a Writer in Literary Prose: Semantic-Space Guidance, Counterfactual Branching, Anticipation of Possible Completion, and Attribution of Agency
Bilingual preprint (English and Japanese editions). This record contains the English and Japanese versions of the same theoretical paper. Abstract Even when a text is grammatically natural and logically well organized, readers may perceive little sense of a writer behind it. Conversely, pedantry, uneven interests, unexpected associations, and expressions that appear inconsiderate of the reader can sometimes evoke a vivid persona. Readability and textual quality alone do not adequately explain this difference. Focusing on literary prose, particularly essays and personal reflections, this paper defines the perceived presence of a writer as the reader's experience of sensing behind a text a speaking subject with a particular perspective, interests, and tendencies of judgment. It then examines possible mechanisms of that experience. The paper distinguishes semantic-space guidance, which shapes the range and relations of possible interpretations, from temporal guidance, which shapes the order in which these possibilities are encountered and the moments at which they are revised. It considers the retrospective traceability of conceptual leaps, the counterfactual consequences of branching as differences in meaning formation that would have followed from another path, and the anticipation of possible completion, which is distinct from predicting a conclusion. Possible completion does not necessarily require a unique interpretation and may characterize works that sustain multiple readings. On this basis, the paper proposes that one mechanism of perceived presence involves readers inferring alternative expressive possibilities and attributing the reasons for realized choices to a subject. It also distinguishes the self-image presented by an author from the persona constructed by a reader, and examines a recursive relation in which the resulting speaker model guides subsequent comprehension and anticipation of completion. The evocation of a persona, attribution of agency, and perceived person-specificity are treated as distinct phenomena, with readers' knowledge and interpretive attitudes specified as conditions of application. The proposed framework does not determine whether an actual author is human or whether a text is good; rather, it offers a testable account of the relation between meaning comprehension and the perceived presence of a subject.
Authors
- Suzume Suzume
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24397045
- Primary Topic
- Narrative Theory and Analysis
- Type
- preprint