Clausius Entropy as a Characteristic of a Thermodynamic System: The Primary Definition, Its Objective Status, and the Problem of Confusion with Boltzmann Entropy
The article recalls the original meaning of the term "entropy," introduced by Rudolf Clausius in 1865. Clausius entropy is a rigorously defined thermodynamic quantity: dS = dQ_rev / T. It is defined through heat and temperature, is a state function, and does not depend on the observer, on knowledge, on uncertainty, or on the choice of macro-variables. It is an operational, objective characteristic of a system. In 1877, Ludwig Boltzmann introduced another quantity, also called entropy: S = k ln W, where W is the number of microstates compatible with a given macrostate. This quantity is statistical: it depends on the choice of macrodescription and on the division of phase space into cells. It introduces coarse-graining, which Clausius does not have. The numerical coincidence of the two quantities in equilibrium systems was perceived as their identity. From this grew characteristic errors. Statements true of one quantity began to be ascribed to the other. The concepts of observer, knowledge, and uncertainty entered discussions of entropy as if they had always been there. The most conspicuous consequence of the confusion is the paradox of Maxwell's demon. A century and a half of discussion around it relates in large part not to physics but to terminology. Had Clausius entropy not been confused with Boltzmann entropy, the paradox would not have arisen in that form. The stages of criticism are examined: mechanical (Smoluchowski), informational (Szilard, Brillouin), resolution through erasure of memory (Landauer, Bennett). Consequences for contemporary discussions are considered: "entropy as a measure of ignorance," "information as primary reality," and "entropy depending on the observer." An appeal for terminological rigor is formulated. Open question: how the two entropies relate ontologically. None of the positions is chosen.
Authors
- Alexander Yourievitch Kotelnikov (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0007-3121-8810)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24392162
- Primary Topic
- Advanced Thermodynamics and Statistical Mechanics
- Type
- preprint