Alternative Masculinity and Nationalism: Legacy of Gandhi and Koirala in Current Political Development in Nepal and India

This paper aims to analyze the alternative masculinity on the autobiographies of M. K. Gandhi and B. P. Koirala that enhance nationalism as a tool for denial of effeminacy, imposed upon males by colonial/ despotic rulers. Nationalistic stance of both Gandhi and Koirala empowered them with the confident alternative masculinity of psychological healing from age old pathology of femininity- in- masculinity. Indian and Nepali people followed warrior class masculinities, the idea of manhood associated with martial prowess, expression of sexual relations, protection of the chastity of woman, and muscular strength. Outsiders in India and Ranas in Nepal effeminized common people representing them as weak, poor, in primitive state, and hence not able to self-rule. Ranas themselves followed the hegemonic masculinity ideals set by the British and effeminized common people in order to rule them over. To fight against such rulers, disregarding hegemonic masculinity and setting alternative forms of masculinity based on spiritualism strengthening people and nationalism was necessary for both Gandhi and Koirala. The primary texts for this study are Gandhi’s An Autobiography: The Story of my Experiment with Truth and Koirala’s Atmabritanta. Theoretical light has been obtained from masculinity theories─ particularly Ashis Nandy’s premises on impenetrability of Indian spirituality, Parama Roy’s interpretation of Gandhian grammar of diet and renunciation, Revathi Krishnaswamy’s postulation on effeminacy and various forms of masculinities, and Sanjeev Uprety’s notion of mimicry and masculinity. The alternative form of masculinity actively constructed and practiced by Gandhi and Koirala, in the process of resistance against the despotic rulers, not only protected them from being effeminate but also helped reshape the male body into a source of energy. Indeed, such masculinity has become the role model for the present day political movements in Indian and Nepali polity.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Contemporary Research An Interdisciplinary Academic Journal
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3126/craiaj.v9i2.102351
Primary Topic
Gender and Feminist Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Alternative Masculinity and Nationalism: Legacy of Gandhi and Koirala in Current Political Development in Nepal and India

Dipak Raj Joshi
2 links
Contemporary Research An Interdisciplinary Academic Journal
Gender and Feminist Studies
article

Alternative Masculinity and Nationalism: Legacy of Gandhi and Koirala in Current Political Development in Nepal and India

Dipak Raj Joshi
article en

Abstract

This paper aims to analyze the alternative masculinity on the autobiographies of M. K. Gandhi and B. P. Koirala that enhance nationalism as a tool for denial of effeminacy, imposed upon males by colonial/ despotic rulers. Nationalistic stance of both Gandhi and Koirala empowered them with the confident alternative masculinity of psychological healing from age old pathology of femininity- in- masculinity. Indian and Nepali people followed warrior class masculinities, the idea of manhood associated with martial prowess, expression of sexual relations, protection of the chastity of woman, and muscular strength. Outsiders in India and Ranas in Nepal effeminized common people representing them as weak, poor, in primitive state, and hence not able to self-rule. Ranas themselves followed the hegemonic masculinity ideals set by the British and effeminized common people in order to rule them over. To fight against such rulers, disregarding hegemonic masculinity and setting alternative forms of masculinity based on spiritualism strengthening people and nationalism was necessary for both Gandhi and Koirala. The primary texts for this study are Gandhi’s An Autobiography: The Story of my Experiment with Truth and Koirala’s Atmabritanta. Theoretical light has been obtained from masculinity theories─ particularly Ashis Nandy’s premises on impenetrability of Indian spirituality, Parama Roy’s interpretation of Gandhian grammar of diet and renunciation, Revathi Krishnaswamy’s postulation on effeminacy and various forms of masculinities, and Sanjeev Uprety’s notion of mimicry and masculinity. The alternative form of masculinity actively constructed and practiced by Gandhi and Koirala, in the process of resistance against the despotic rulers, not only protected them from being effeminate but also helped reshape the male body into a source of energy. Indeed, such masculinity has become the role model for the present day political movements in Indian and Nepali polity.

Contemporary Research An Interdisciplinary Academic JournalVol. 9(2)
Tribhuvan University (NP)
Gender equality
Gender and Feminist Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon
Alternative Masculinity and Nationalism: Legacy of Gandhi and Koirala in Current Political Development in Nepal and India — Dipak Raj Joshi · Contemporary Research An Interdisciplinary Academic Journal (2026) | TGRS Research Map | TGRS