Aggregation Into a Nonexistent Composite Individual: Why the Average Person May Be No One
This conceptual paper introduces Aggregation Into a Nonexistent Composite Individual, a structural constraint in the Representation and Measurement series of On Human Modeling. An average height, an average reach, and an average weight can each describe the same population accurately, yet no member may have all three measurements together. To find out whether anyone fits the resulting profile, and how typical that person would be, the paper asks how many individual records meet all the criteria at once. In 1994, Vitaly Komar and Alexander Melamid painted America’s Most Wanted using the results of a poll of 1,001 adults. Blue led the favorite-color question, and bodies of water led the question about outdoor scenes. Among respondents who wanted a famous person in the painting, historical figures were the leading choice. The artists chose George Washington and placed him beside a lake in a predominantly blue landscape. The published tallies leave open how many respondents wanted those features together. In 1945, the Cleveland Health Museum held a contest to find an Ohio woman whose measurements matched Norma, a statue based on compiled measurements of young white Americans. Few of the 3,863 entrants approached the statue’s dimensions. Martha Skidmore came closest, and her measurements still differed from Norma’s. The contest shows how rarely entrants approached the composite. How closely anyone in the original group matched it remains open. The paper places this constraint alongside Adolphe Quetelet’s account of the average man, whose combined qualities he treated as a hypothetical ideal. The same question arises when an AI assistant uses survey results to describe a “typical user” who prefers short answers, spoken replies, and automatic follow-up questions. Each preference could lead on its own question. Counting the respondents who chose all three would show how many people the description actually fits.
Authors
- Alexandra Cary
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24409133
- Primary Topic
- Social Representations and Identity
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00