FROM EXAMINATION ROOM TO COURTROOM: THE ROLE OF MEDICAL EXPERTS AND HEALTH WORKERS IN THE INVESTIGATION, PROSECUTION, AND ADJUDICATION OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE CASES IN UGANDA
Domestic violence remains a major global and national public health and human rights concern, with criminal justice systems increasingly dependent on medico-legal evidence to support investigation, prosecution, and adjudication. Because most incidents occur in private settings with few eyewitnesses, medical documentation and expert interpretation are often central to corroborating victim accounts and establishing proof of harm. The World Health Organisation (2024) estimates that nearly one in three women globally has experienced physical and/or sexual violence, while in Uganda, 51% of ever-married women report spousal violence (UBOS & ICF, 2023). Despite this burden, limited scholarship has examined the integrated role of medical experts and health workers across the criminal justice continuum, particularly in low-resource settings where documentation and reporting challenges are pronounced. This article examines the contribution of medical experts and health workers to the investigation, prosecution, and adjudication of domestic violence cases in Uganda. Guided by an interpretivist paradigm, the study adopts a qualitative doctrinal and socio-legal design. Data were obtained through documentary review of statutes, policy frameworks, institutional reports, case law, and peer-reviewed literature, and analysed using thematic content analysis. Findings show that medical experts and health workers play a critical evidentiary role by identifying and classifying injuries, preparing medico-legal reports, preserving forensic evidence, and providing expert testimony to assist legal actors in interpreting clinical findings. These functions strengthen evidentiary reliability, improve investigative quality, and support prosecutorial and judicial decision-making. However, their effectiveness is constrained by systemic challenges, including shortages of trained forensic personnel, limited medico-legal training, weak infrastructure, inadequate laboratory and documentation systems, and poor coordination between health and justice sectors. These weaknesses contribute to evidentiary gaps, case attrition, delayed justice, and reduced conviction rates, ultimately undermining the effectiveness and credibility of the criminal justice response to domestic violence. Keywords: Domestic violence, Medico-legal evidence, medical experts, Criminal justice system, Uganda.
Authors
- Farouq Lubega
Publication Details
- Journal
- African Journal of Emerging Issues
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- Primary Topic
- Intimate Partner and Family Violence
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00