BEYOND THE EXECUTIVE PROFILE: WHERE RESEARCH ON TOP MANAGEMENT TEAMS, CORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND FIRM PERFORMANCE IS HEADING
Purpose. Four decades after Hambrick and Mason (1984), the claim that top management team (TMT) characteristics shape firm performance, and condition how corporate governance pays off, remains influential but unevenly supported. This review asks what the cumulative evidence now supports and where the research frontier is moving. Design. A critical, integrative narrative review of 65 verified sources: meta-analyses, methodological exchanges, systematic reviews published 2020–2026, and regulatory documents. Concentrated-ownership and frontier markets are treated as theoretically informative settings rather than peripheral replications, with Kenya's Nairobi Securities Exchange (NSE) as the worked example. A survey-based moderation study from that market serves as a reference point for the dominant regional design. Findings. The best-supported executive effect is modest, runs mainly through strategic actions and depends on discretion. The field is moving beyond the demographic profile of executives toward five questions: how executive roles are structured, how far owners and institutions let executives act, how executive psychology can be measured from archival traces, which outcomes beyond profit executives answer for, and how artificial intelligence (AI) changes the capabilities that matter at the strategic apex. Survey-based moderation designs cannot discriminate between these accounts. Contribution. The review states six contested debates and seven falsifiable propositions, each testable with archival data in any market, proposes minimum design standards for TMT–governance research, and draws implications for boards, regulators and journal editors. Keywords: upper echelons theory; top management team; corporate governance; managerial discretion; ownership concentration; artificial intelligence; frontier markets; narrative review
Authors
- Samwel Omwenga Makini
Publication Details
- Journal
- African Journal of Emerging Issues
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- Primary Topic
- Corporate Finance and Governance
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00