Equal-Budget Benchmarking of Metaheuristics for Joint Placement and Sizing of Distributed Generation and FACTS Devices in Transmission Networks under Renewable Uncertainty

Background: Placing distributed generation (DG) and flexible AC transmission system (FACTS) devices together can reduce losses and support voltage in transmission networks, but solver comparisons often use unequal computing budgets and report the benefit at rated DG output. Methods: Five metaheuristics (PSO, a swarm variant of MVMO-SH, a Monte Carlo hybrid PSO (MC-HPSO), GWO and DE) were compared on the joint placement and sizing of two DG units, one STATCOM and one TCSC on the IEEE 30-, 57- and 118-bus systems. Each candidate was evaluated by a full NewtonRaphson power flow, each solver received 6000 power-flow solves per run, constraints were handled by a linear penalty, and 20 independent runs per solver were compared using Kruskal-Wallis, Holmadjusted Mann-Whitney tests and the Vargha-Delaney effect size. Returned placements were also evaluated over 1000 held-out wind and solar scenarios, and two scenario-aware DE baselines were added. Results: Base-case losses of 17.56, 27.86 and 132.86 MW were reduced at rated output by 40 %, 48 % and 17 %, with MVMO-SH best on the 30- and 118-bus systems and DE best on the 57-bus system. MVMO-SH and DE were the most reliable solvers; MC-HPSO, which performs one tenth of the fitness evaluations, was poor at rated output. The expected loss reduction over the held-out scenarios was only 4 % to 11 %, mainly because the mean wind and solar capacity factors are low. On the IEEE 57-bus system, placements that were feasible at rated output still violated a voltage limit in most scenarios. Conclusions: Rated-output loss reductions overstate the benefit of DG and FACTS placement under renewable uncertainty, so feasibility should be checked over scenarios; MVMO-SH and DE are suitable solvers under an equal budget. Code and per-run data are provided.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Engineering Research Express
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1088/2631-8695/aec49e
Primary Topic
Optimal Power Flow Distribution
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Equal-Budget Benchmarking of Metaheuristics for Joint Placement and Sizing of Distributed Generation and FACTS Devices in Transmission Networks under Renewable Uncertainty

Mohd Tauseef Khan, Anurag Tripathi, Ashish Tripathi
Engineering Research Express
Optimal Power Flow Distribution
article

Equal-Budget Benchmarking of Metaheuristics for Joint Placement and Sizing of Distributed Generation and FACTS Devices in Transmission Networks under Renewable Uncertainty

Mohd Tauseef Khan, Anurag Tripathi, Ashish Tripathi
article en

Abstract

Background: Placing distributed generation (DG) and flexible AC transmission system (FACTS) devices together can reduce losses and support voltage in transmission networks, but solver comparisons often use unequal computing budgets and report the benefit at rated DG output. Methods: Five metaheuristics (PSO, a swarm variant of MVMO-SH, a Monte Carlo hybrid PSO (MC-HPSO), GWO and DE) were compared on the joint placement and sizing of two DG units, one STATCOM and one TCSC on the IEEE 30-, 57- and 118-bus systems. Each candidate was evaluated by a full NewtonRaphson power flow, each solver received 6000 power-flow solves per run, constraints were handled by a linear penalty, and 20 independent runs per solver were compared using Kruskal-Wallis, Holmadjusted Mann-Whitney tests and the Vargha-Delaney effect size. Returned placements were also evaluated over 1000 held-out wind and solar scenarios, and two scenario-aware DE baselines were added. Results: Base-case losses of 17.56, 27.86 and 132.86 MW were reduced at rated output by 40 %, 48 % and 17 %, with MVMO-SH best on the 30- and 118-bus systems and DE best on the 57-bus system. MVMO-SH and DE were the most reliable solvers; MC-HPSO, which performs one tenth of the fitness evaluations, was poor at rated output. The expected loss reduction over the held-out scenarios was only 4 % to 11 %, mainly because the mean wind and solar capacity factors are low. On the IEEE 57-bus system, placements that were feasible at rated output still violated a voltage limit in most scenarios. Conclusions: Rated-output loss reductions overstate the benefit of DG and FACTS placement under renewable uncertainty, so feasibility should be checked over scenarios; MVMO-SH and DE are suitable solvers under an equal budget. Code and per-run data are provided.

Engineering Research Express
Rajkiya Engineering College Banda (IN)
Optimal Power Flow Distribution
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon