Archer, Donati, Emirbayer, Crossley, and the Sociology of Belonging: Relational Ontology, Individual Agency, Social Structures, and Historical Transformation

This article examines the relationship between contemporary relational sociology and the Sociology of Belonging through a systematic comparison with Margaret Archer, Pierpaolo Donati, Mustafa Emirbayer, and Nick Crossley. Relational sociology has made a fundamental contribution by demonstrating that individuals, identities, institutions, and social structures cannot be adequately understood independently of the relationships through which they are constituted. This insight provides an important sociological foundation for the principle Being Is Belonging. However, the Sociology of Belonging advances a broader ontological framework. Being Is Belonging is not restricted to human society but applies to three interconnected existential strata: material, biological, and institutional-human reality. Moreover, this principle is inseparably connected with three additional ontological principles: Imperfect Belonging, Dual Temporality, and Stratified Reality. The material stratum establishes conditions for biological and institutional-human existence, while biological evolution establishes essential preconditions for human institutional development. Consequently, human society cannot be adequately understood without its evolutionary foundations. Affective attachment, cooperation, competition, and social learning precede specifically human institutional arrangements. Imperfect Belonging establishes that individuals are ontologically differentiated from the systems within which they develop. Human beings are socially constituted without being completely determined by their social institutions. This differentiation creates the potential for individual freedom, creativity, and institutional innovation. The social realization of individual creativity, however, depends on institutional arrangements. Economic opportunities, social recognition, and political power determine whether differentiated capacities contribute to collective development, reproduce established inequalities, or generate destructive conflict. Dual Temporality explains the recursive relationship between synchronic organization and diachronic transformation. Existing material, biological, conceptual, and institutional conditions influence historical possibilities, while individual and collective action produces new configurations. This process contributes to path dependence and the historical diversity of societies. The article also situates the Sociology of Belonging within a broader intellectual program connecting philosophy, sociology, ethics, and economics. Philosophy develops the ontological foundations; sociology explains institutional organization and historical transformation; ethics evaluates the conditions supporting individual well-being and social adaptability; and the Economics of Belonging investigates five objectives: economic growth, economic stability, appropriate income distribution, appropriate distribution of capabilities, and the satisfaction of belonging among individuals and groups. This interdisciplinary perspective provides a framework for examining how markets, democratic institutions, individual freedom, and expanding middle-class demand may contribute to innovation and economic development under historically specific conditions. The article compares the five theoretical approaches across twelve fundamental sociological problems and twenty theoretical dimensions, identifies their complementary contributions, and develops propositions for comparative empirical investigation. Its central conclusion is that the ontological sociality of human beings does not diminish the importance of individual freedom and creativity. On the contrary, the principle of Imperfect Belonging explains why differentiated individuals can become sources of institutional transformation, while the organization of society determines whether their creative capacities can be effectively incorporated into collective development.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24376150
Primary Topic
Critical Realism in Sociology
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Archer, Donati, Emirbayer, Crossley, and the Sociology of Belonging: Relational Ontology, Individual Agency, Social Structures, and Historical Transformation

Carlos Federico Obregon Diaz
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Critical Realism in Sociology
preprint

Archer, Donati, Emirbayer, Crossley, and the Sociology of Belonging: Relational Ontology, Individual Agency, Social Structures, and Historical Transformation

Carlos Federico Obregon Diaz
preprint en

Abstract

This article examines the relationship between contemporary relational sociology and the Sociology of Belonging through a systematic comparison with Margaret Archer, Pierpaolo Donati, Mustafa Emirbayer, and Nick Crossley. Relational sociology has made a fundamental contribution by demonstrating that individuals, identities, institutions, and social structures cannot be adequately understood independently of the relationships through which they are constituted. This insight provides an important sociological foundation for the principle Being Is Belonging. However, the Sociology of Belonging advances a broader ontological framework. Being Is Belonging is not restricted to human society but applies to three interconnected existential strata: material, biological, and institutional-human reality. Moreover, this principle is inseparably connected with three additional ontological principles: Imperfect Belonging, Dual Temporality, and Stratified Reality. The material stratum establishes conditions for biological and institutional-human existence, while biological evolution establishes essential preconditions for human institutional development. Consequently, human society cannot be adequately understood without its evolutionary foundations. Affective attachment, cooperation, competition, and social learning precede specifically human institutional arrangements. Imperfect Belonging establishes that individuals are ontologically differentiated from the systems within which they develop. Human beings are socially constituted without being completely determined by their social institutions. This differentiation creates the potential for individual freedom, creativity, and institutional innovation. The social realization of individual creativity, however, depends on institutional arrangements. Economic opportunities, social recognition, and political power determine whether differentiated capacities contribute to collective development, reproduce established inequalities, or generate destructive conflict. Dual Temporality explains the recursive relationship between synchronic organization and diachronic transformation. Existing material, biological, conceptual, and institutional conditions influence historical possibilities, while individual and collective action produces new configurations. This process contributes to path dependence and the historical diversity of societies. The article also situates the Sociology of Belonging within a broader intellectual program connecting philosophy, sociology, ethics, and economics. Philosophy develops the ontological foundations; sociology explains institutional organization and historical transformation; ethics evaluates the conditions supporting individual well-being and social adaptability; and the Economics of Belonging investigates five objectives: economic growth, economic stability, appropriate income distribution, appropriate distribution of capabilities, and the satisfaction of belonging among individuals and groups. This interdisciplinary perspective provides a framework for examining how markets, democratic institutions, individual freedom, and expanding middle-class demand may contribute to innovation and economic development under historically specific conditions. The article compares the five theoretical approaches across twelve fundamental sociological problems and twenty theoretical dimensions, identifies their complementary contributions, and develops propositions for comparative empirical investigation. Its central conclusion is that the ontological sociality of human beings does not diminish the importance of individual freedom and creativity. On the contrary, the principle of Imperfect Belonging explains why differentiated individuals can become sources of institutional transformation, while the organization of society determines whether their creative capacities can be effectively incorporated into collective development.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Critical Realism in Sociology
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon