Which pairs of values on the E-function slice are Möbius-related? A checked account with a census test
Take the continued fractions b_0 + K(n>=1) (a_0 + a_1 n)/(b_0 + b_1 n) with rational coefficients whose value is transcendental and given by Kummer's function 1F1 or by 0F1 (classes 1, 2, 4, 7 of an earlier classification). For two such values K_i, K_j we ask when a + b K_i + c K_j + d K_iK_j = 0 holds with rational (a, b, c, d) != 0. Four families of pairs are linked by classical contiguity, transformation and recurrence formulas of the DLMF, and their values are Möbius-related. For 7,491,180 other pairs (from a census of 4,056 rows) we show that no such relation exists, modulo statements pinned in papers of Gorelov, Beukers and Singer and derivations of ours and the reading of (11) for q = 2. For 656,088 pairs the question stays open. A pair of values that is algebraically dependent but not Möbius-related is given. A pre-registered census test, run by two independent readers, found no mismatch on 166,993 holdout pairs. Labels are proved modulo pinned statements, VERIFIED, EXPLORATORY, CONJECTURED and UNCLEAR, used as defined in Section 2. Changes from version 1.0.0. Version 1.0.0 is the Zenodo record 24356652 (concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24356651); that record stays as published. This version corrects the matrix of the class-7 rows in Section 4.2 for the 192 rows with g a non-positive integer (the form of version 1.0.0 stands for the other rows); extends Statement B by the lemmas of Section 4.4 to the pieces HB x HB, HB x COV, HB x PHI and PHI x COV, so that no Möbius relation is shown on 7,491,180 pairs instead of 3,932,172; reduces the open part from 4,215,096 to 656,088 pairs and adds a searched-pairs column to the coverage table, with the searched pairs of Gorelov 2016 and of the remaining part counted separately; adds Singer's lecture notes to the sources; and corrects the wording of version 1.0.0 on the Remark of Gorelov 2016, on the reading of condition (11) for q = 2 and on a page pin of the Beukers entry. What is classical. The four link families are contiguity relations of Kummer's function 1F1, Kummer's transformation (DLMF 13.2.39), the recurrence of the modified Bessel functions and Kummer's second transformation (DLMF 13.6.9); each "if" direction follows from these. The "only if" direction rests on Gorelov's theorems on algebraic independence (2021, 2016). They are statements about the values of a hypergeometric function and of its derivative, not about the values of the continued fractions; the passage from the one to the other is our derivation, and the outcome is labelled accordingly. This derivation was not found in the sources consulted, and it is not claimed to be absent from the literature. No claim of priority is made. The note builds on an earlier note (Zenodo concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24337722) for the setting, the classification and the reading R1 of Perron's text; none of its proofs is repeated. Checks. A pre-registered census test was run by two readers, A and B, in separate sandboxes holding only the frozen specification. On the 166,993 holdout pairs both readers agree and the agreed outcome equals the prediction (0 mismatches); both were valid on 314 controls. An earlier run of this test, version 1, was closed as not valid because 127 of the 314 controls were excluded by its specification; the note reports the closure. The census test checks Möbius relations between pairs and says nothing about algebraic independence. The study is recorded in an append-only local ledger (study C14): seq 18 (entry_sha256 aeb2b7f8db77e0baee21f5185b795cec69363e6d5163ba6d986b691a6780e055), seq 19 (entry_sha256 3746ba4ad86e47c1870b17fcb80fe72919792e25e605a22ba0689406310fbdbe), seq 20 (entry_sha256 63de066943e3f04558ec6bcf4f4a819ad252dcc9fae9fb8511d1135c290844aa), seq 21 (entry_sha256 c2df49ddf25b1c119c1f7d08dd9f9789acf04da30114074b671e33a7565b07ab), seq 22 (entry_sha256 43cc013eef387026f1e0e759f1eb5c56cfa35cb7e4dde32eacb4ea133da8529a). The dossier of the lemmas of Section 4.4 was checked by two independent AI sessions (C15cA and C15cB) under the same protocol; their verdict files are verdicts_C15cA.csv and verdicts_C15cB.csv. A proofreading check of the text (C15e) led to the wording corrections named in the changes above. The coverage counts of the note are computed by script and add up to the 8,223,540 pairs of the census: 76,272 link pairs, 7,491,180 pairs with no Möbius relation, covered by Gorelov's theorems and the lemmas of Section 4.4, and 656,088 pairs that remain open. The checks show consistency; the proofs hold modulo the statements pinned in the note, and no part of the work has been refereed. The source searches, computations, checks and drafting of this note were carried out with AI assistance (Claude by Anthropic, and AI agents run through the GitHub Copilot CLI), under a pre-registered and hash-ledgered protocol. The author directed the work, made every decision recorded here, and takes responsibility for the content. Files. note.pdf (the note), and the supplementary files: C14c_RESULT.md, C14c_v2_result_tables.md, C14c_v2_validity_table.md, prereg_C14c_v2.md, C14c_v1_CLOSE_ENTRY_2026-11-18.md, candidates.md, cover_by_claim.csv, cover_by_rowtype.csv, category_counts_r1.csv, join_confusion.csv, s01_statementC.py, s01_statementC.log.txt, s12_c14g_counts.py, s12_c14g_counts.log.txt, s13_class2_identity.py, s13_class2_identity.log.txt, s10_halfC.out.txt, s11_degen.out.txt, gorelov_reading.md, dossier_c15d.md, pins_c15.md, open_partition.csv, pins_c15b.md, coverage_c15b.csv, verdicts_C15cA.csv, verdicts_C15cB.csv, s01_class7_check_v2.py, s01_class7_check_v2.log.txt, class7_check_rows.csv, s02_searched_counts_v2.py, s02_searched_counts_v2.log.txt, searched_counts.json. Licensing. All files of this record, including the scripts, are under CC BY 4.0.
Authors
- Papanokechi (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0000-6192-8273)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24356651
- Primary Topic
- Advanced Mathematical Identities
- Type
- preprint