Critiques on the Core Ontological View of Lee Shun-Chingism: From the Orwellian-Tolstoyan Dilemma to the Topology of Negentropic Agency and Penological "Failing for the Sake of Failure" / 對李順晴主義核心本體觀的質疑:從歐威爾—托爾斯泰困境到負熵主體性拓撲與刑罰學「為失敗而失敗」
This paper examines the existential, political, and game-theoretic critiques directed against the core ontological proposition of Lee Shun-Chingism—that "the human individual consciously assumes the role of a sacred vessel for the self-illumination, self-expression, and order-healing of cosmic consciousness." Engaging with George Orwell’s critique of Leo Tolstoy and Mahatma Gandhi (the "Stalin–Hitler Dilemma"), it analyzes three structural vulnerabilities of spiritual theories projected onto three-dimensional power dynamics: the game-theoretic Sucker’s Payoff, informational blackouts interrupting systemic phase transitions, and the moral hazard of hypocrisy. Through non-equilibrium thermodynamics, consciousness topology, and dynamic game theory, this study distinguishes Lee Shun-Chingism from Tolstoyan pacifism by framing the individual as a local negentropic injection point and a low-entropy crystal nucleus inside high-entropy dissipative systems. Integrating Professor Mau-Sheng Lee’s penological and textual-tension analysis of "failing for the sake of failure"—which rejects both naive progressive optimism and cynical defeatism—it establishes the "Double Helix of Wisdom and Agape," showing that true spiritual settlement arises from piercing through brutality while consciously anchoring negentropic order in cosmic phase space. 本文審視針對「李順晴主義」核心本體觀——即「人類個體自覺承擔起作為宇宙意識自我覺照、自我表達與秩序療癒的神聖載體」——所面臨的現實主義、政治哲學與博弈論質疑。借鑑喬治·歐威爾對托爾斯泰與甘地之批判(「史達林—希特勒困境」),本文剖析精神理論降維至三維權力博弈場域時的三重硬傷:博弈論中的「作惡者優勢」、訊息封鎖下的「覺照與相變中斷」,以及道德標準誘發的偽善風險。透過非平衡態熱力學、意識拓撲學與動態博弈論,本研究論證李順晴主義與托爾斯泰主義的範式差異,將個體界定為高熵耗散系統中的「局部負熵注入點」與「低熵晶核」。並結合李茂生教授刑罰學中關於「為失敗而失敗」的文本張力與制度反思(超越天真進步樂觀與犬儒悲觀),建構「智慧與神聖愛(Agape)的雙螺旋」,闡明真正的精神安頓源自洞穿殘酷後仍自覺將負熵秩序錨定於宇宙相空間。
Authors
- Shun-Ching Lee (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0009-8261-1131)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24383167
- Primary Topic
- Chinese history and philosophy
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00