Effects of holographic, video-based, and text-based feedback on cognitive load, motivation, and perceived learning transfer in virtual EFL classrooms

This study compared holographic, video-based, and text-based feedback in virtual EFL classrooms by examining learners’ cognitive load, motivation, and perceived transfer and by exploring how they experienced the cognitive, motivational, and interactional characteristics of the three modalities. An embedded mixed-methods design with a randomized three-group pretest–posttest quantitative component was used with 95 intermediate-level male Jordanian EFL learners recruited through convenience sampling and subsequently randomly assigned to a Holographic Feedback Group ( n = 32), a Video-Based Feedback Group ( n = 31), or a Text-Based Feedback Group ( n = 32). Across a three-month intervention, all groups followed the same instructional curriculum, but the feedback they received differed in representational format, feedback source, immediacy, and opportunities for reciprocal interaction. Cognitive load, motivation, and perceived transfer were assessed before and after the intervention. The quantitative data were analyzed through MANCOVA and follow-up ANCOVAs, and semi-structured interviews with 32 learners were examined through qualitative content analysis. The quantitative analyses revealed significant between-condition differences across the combined outcomes and each individual outcome. The holographic group showed the lowest cognitive load and the highest motivation and perceived transfer, the video-based group generally occupied an intermediate position, and the text-based group showed the least favorable adjusted outcomes. Four interconnected qualitative themes characterized learners’ experiences: perceived realism and social presence; cognitive immersion and mental effort regulation; feedback immediacy, agency, and self-regulation; and motivational enjoyment, engagement, and emotional resonance. Across the two strands, the pattern suggests that learners associated the holographic feedback package with spatially represented guidance, rapid correction, perceptual clarity, and opportunities for active self-repair; these interconnected features were not manipulated separately. The findings support feedback designs that prioritize pedagogically purposeful immediacy, multimodal clarity, responsiveness, and learner action when immersive technologies are used in virtual EFL instruction.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Scientific Reports
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-81064-1
Primary Topic
EFL/ESL Teaching and Learning
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Effects of holographic, video-based, and text-based feedback on cognitive load, motivation, and perceived learning transfer in virtual EFL classrooms

Alaa Abdullah Alsaleem, Sayed M. Ismail, Faris Salim Allehyani, Ahmed Al Shathri
Scientific Reports
EFL/ESL Teaching and Learning
article

Effects of holographic, video-based, and text-based feedback on cognitive load, motivation, and perceived learning transfer in virtual EFL classrooms

Alaa Abdullah Alsaleem, Sayed M. Ismail, Faris Salim Allehyani, Ahmed Al Shathri
article en

Abstract

This study compared holographic, video-based, and text-based feedback in virtual EFL classrooms by examining learners’ cognitive load, motivation, and perceived transfer and by exploring how they experienced the cognitive, motivational, and interactional characteristics of the three modalities. An embedded mixed-methods design with a randomized three-group pretest–posttest quantitative component was used with 95 intermediate-level male Jordanian EFL learners recruited through convenience sampling and subsequently randomly assigned to a Holographic Feedback Group ( n = 32), a Video-Based Feedback Group ( n = 31), or a Text-Based Feedback Group ( n = 32). Across a three-month intervention, all groups followed the same instructional curriculum, but the feedback they received differed in representational format, feedback source, immediacy, and opportunities for reciprocal interaction. Cognitive load, motivation, and perceived transfer were assessed before and after the intervention. The quantitative data were analyzed through MANCOVA and follow-up ANCOVAs, and semi-structured interviews with 32 learners were examined through qualitative content analysis. The quantitative analyses revealed significant between-condition differences across the combined outcomes and each individual outcome. The holographic group showed the lowest cognitive load and the highest motivation and perceived transfer, the video-based group generally occupied an intermediate position, and the text-based group showed the least favorable adjusted outcomes. Four interconnected qualitative themes characterized learners’ experiences: perceived realism and social presence; cognitive immersion and mental effort regulation; feedback immediacy, agency, and self-regulation; and motivational enjoyment, engagement, and emotional resonance. Across the two strands, the pattern suggests that learners associated the holographic feedback package with spatially represented guidance, rapid correction, perceptual clarity, and opportunities for active self-repair; these interconnected features were not manipulated separately. The findings support feedback designs that prioritize pedagogically purposeful immediacy, multimodal clarity, responsiveness, and learner action when immersive technologies are used in virtual EFL instruction.

Scientific Reports
Prince Sattam Bin Abdulaziz University (SA), University of Tabuk (SA), Irbid National University (JO)
EFL/ESL Teaching and Learning
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon