The Impact of Ambulance Crew Communication on Patient Safety and Prehospital Care Quality: A Systematic Review

Background Ambulance care depends on rapid and accurate information exchange within crews, between field teams and dispatchers, and at the interface with emergency departments (EDs). Incomplete verbal reports, interruptions, uncertain leadership, inconsistent communication formats, and delayed pre-alerts may undermine situational awareness and continuity of care. Although communication improvement is widely recommended, its effect on measured patient safety and prehospital quality requires careful differentiation between communication-process outcomes and patient outcomes. Objective To critically synthesize original research published from 2019 through 2025 on ambulance crew communication, examining information completeness, teamwork, clinical handover, patient safety indicators, and timeliness or quality of prehospital care. Methods A structured, PICOS-informed literature synthesis was developed from traceable primary articles identified through targeted checks of PubMed-indexed records and original journal publications. Seventeen relevant primary reports were organized into crew teamwork, ambulance-to-ED handover, dispatch and pre-arrival alerts, and communication-supported care pathways. A narrative approach was used because study designs, settings, interventions, and outcomes varied markedly. The 17 reports form a verified, curated evidence set rather than the documented yield of a fully audited database search. Therefore, unverified PRISMA record counts and formal risk-of-bias ratings are not presented. Results Structured communication approaches improved several immediate handover measures. In a Canadian trauma-centre implementation study, IMIST-AMBO was used in 80 of 140 reviewed handovers (57%), and mean handover duration was shorter than during the preimplementation comparison (1 min 58 s versus 2 min 47 s). A German ISOBAR implementation trial involving 651 handovers found significantly better key-information transfer and an increase in information retained by receiving physicians and nurses. In a 2025 United States quality-improvement evaluation, team-based EMS handoff was associated with a 55-minute shorter mean interval to patient disposition, but not a significant difference in ED departure time. Qualitative and survey studies from Iceland, Norway, the United Kingdom, and Saudi Arabia identified interruptions, mismatched expectations, role ambiguity, and limited training as recurrent problems. Direct reductions in medication errors, mortality, or other adverse events were seldom demonstrated. Conclusion Ambulance communication is a plausible and modifiable component of safe, high-quality prehospital care. The strongest available evidence supports improvements in information transfer, team coordination, and selected care-process times rather than a universal proven reduction in patient harm. Shared structured reports, protected listening time, explicit transfer of responsibility, reciprocal confirmation, and context-sensitive training should be implemented with objective safety monitoring.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Arabian Gulf Journal of Humanities and Social Studies
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.64355/agjhss72041
Primary Topic
Hospital Admissions and Outcomes
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

The Impact of Ambulance Crew Communication on Patient Safety and Prehospital Care Quality: A Systematic Review

1- Researcher: Abdullah Mohammad A 2- Researcher: Udaei Khalid J. Bogari 3- Researcher: Rayan Khalaf B. Alharbi 4- Researcher: Meshari Hassan K. Alzahrani 5- Researcher: Omar Munaji A. Nafea 6- Researcher: Abdulilah Yahya S. Alharbi 7- Researcher: Sulaiman Abdullah S. Abdullah 8- Researcher: Mohammed Ahmed B. Almohaimeed
Arabian Gulf Journal of Humanities and Social Studies
Hospital Admissions and Outcomes
article

The Impact of Ambulance Crew Communication on Patient Safety and Prehospital Care Quality: A Systematic Review

1- Researcher: Abdullah Mohammad A 2- Researcher: Udaei Khalid J. Bogari 3- Researcher: Rayan Khalaf B. Alharbi 4- Researcher: Meshari Hassan K. Alzahrani 5- Researcher: Omar Munaji A. Nafea 6- Researcher: Abdulilah Yahya S. Alharbi 7- Researcher: Sulaiman Abdullah S. Abdullah 8- Researcher: Mohammed Ahmed B. Almohaimeed
article en

Abstract

Background Ambulance care depends on rapid and accurate information exchange within crews, between field teams and dispatchers, and at the interface with emergency departments (EDs). Incomplete verbal reports, interruptions, uncertain leadership, inconsistent communication formats, and delayed pre-alerts may undermine situational awareness and continuity of care. Although communication improvement is widely recommended, its effect on measured patient safety and prehospital quality requires careful differentiation between communication-process outcomes and patient outcomes. Objective To critically synthesize original research published from 2019 through 2025 on ambulance crew communication, examining information completeness, teamwork, clinical handover, patient safety indicators, and timeliness or quality of prehospital care. Methods A structured, PICOS-informed literature synthesis was developed from traceable primary articles identified through targeted checks of PubMed-indexed records and original journal publications. Seventeen relevant primary reports were organized into crew teamwork, ambulance-to-ED handover, dispatch and pre-arrival alerts, and communication-supported care pathways. A narrative approach was used because study designs, settings, interventions, and outcomes varied markedly. The 17 reports form a verified, curated evidence set rather than the documented yield of a fully audited database search. Therefore, unverified PRISMA record counts and formal risk-of-bias ratings are not presented. Results Structured communication approaches improved several immediate handover measures. In a Canadian trauma-centre implementation study, IMIST-AMBO was used in 80 of 140 reviewed handovers (57%), and mean handover duration was shorter than during the preimplementation comparison (1 min 58 s versus 2 min 47 s). A German ISOBAR implementation trial involving 651 handovers found significantly better key-information transfer and an increase in information retained by receiving physicians and nurses. In a 2025 United States quality-improvement evaluation, team-based EMS handoff was associated with a 55-minute shorter mean interval to patient disposition, but not a significant difference in ED departure time. Qualitative and survey studies from Iceland, Norway, the United Kingdom, and Saudi Arabia identified interruptions, mismatched expectations, role ambiguity, and limited training as recurrent problems. Direct reductions in medication errors, mortality, or other adverse events were seldom demonstrated. Conclusion Ambulance communication is a plausible and modifiable component of safe, high-quality prehospital care. The strongest available evidence supports improvements in information transfer, team coordination, and selected care-process times rather than a universal proven reduction in patient harm. Shared structured reports, protected listening time, explicit transfer of responsibility, reciprocal confirmation, and context-sensitive training should be implemented with objective safety monitoring.

Arabian Gulf Journal of Humanities and Social StudiesVol. 7(20)
Hospital Admissions and Outcomes
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon