Adaptive Mutual-Human Verification: A Universal Framework for Multi-Model Cross-Validation, Human Verification, and Dynamic Verification Switching
The increasing complexity of large language models (LLMs), autonomous agents, and AI-supported decision-making systems has created a growing need for reliable verification mechanisms. Existing approaches include self-verification, model-based evaluation, multi-agent debate, ensemble assessment, automated fact-checking, human review, and human-in-the-loop supervision. However, these approaches are frequently implemented as separate or predetermined verification pathways. A system may rely exclusively on one model, use multiple models throughout the verification process, or require human review at fixed stages, regardless of whether the selected mechanism remains appropriate for the task. This paper introduces Adaptive Mutual-Human Verification (AMHV), a new theoretical framework developed as a functional extension of the Universal Mutual-Human Model (UMHM). AMHV establishes two complementary verification dimensions: Mutual Cross-Validation, in which two or more distinct large language models independently or interactively examine, challenge, compare, and verify information produced by one another; and Human Verification, in which human individuals or groups independently examine evidence, identify errors, assess correctness, and provide authoritative judgments within their designated responsibilities. The central contribution is an adaptive verification architecture that dynamically selects, switches between, combines, and reconfigures these mechanisms according to verification uncertainty, disagreement, evidence sufficiency, task complexity, risk, model capabilities, human expertise, and resource constraints. Unlike architectures that permanently depend on automated verification or predefined human intervention, AMHV treats the verification pathway itself as an adaptive decision variable. The framework introduces Adaptive Verification Selection, Adaptive Verification Switching, Adaptive Verification Combination, Adaptive Verification Reconfiguration, Cross-Model Verification Independence, Verification Escalation, and Verification Return. A formal configuration space, decision-theoretic optimization model, uncertainty-sensitive switching policy, operational architecture, theoretical propositions, application scenarios, governance principles, and empirical evaluation methodology are developed. The framework distinguishes agreement from correctness, model diversity from genuine independence, and human participation from nominal oversight. To the best of our knowledge, this paper is the first to formally articulate this particular UMHM-grounded, function-general verification architecture in which multi-model mutual cross-validation and human verification are treated as distinct but combinable mechanisms governed by explicit adaptive selection, switching, combination, and reconfiguration. This narrowly defined originality claim does not imply that multi-agent verification, automated checking, or human oversight originated with this work. AMHV provides a theoretical foundation for developing verification systems that can move beyond a single predetermined verification pathway and select the most appropriate verification arrangement as operational conditions evolve.
Authors
- Jincheng Zhang (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0005-1860-0009)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24361796
- Primary Topic
- Ethics and Social Impacts of AI
- Type
- preprint