Quantitative Trade-Off Evaluation of Hardened DFFs in 130 nm ProASIC3 Flash-Based FPGAs Under Wide-LET Heavy-Ion Irradiation

Single-event upset (SEU) hardening of native D flip-flops (DFFs) in flash-based field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) lacks unified experimental conditions and quantitative selection criteria; this work implements six DFF structures on one and the same A3PE3000 chip as identical dual 243-bit shift-register test chains. These include an unhardened baseline DFF (BL-DFF), a conventional triple-modular-redundancy DFF (TMR-DFF), three delay-filtering TMR-DFF variants (DF-TMR-DFF), and one dual-path combinational-logic-replica TMR-DFF (DCLR-TMR-DFF). Realized DF-TMR-DFF filtering windows are set by on-chip process–voltage–temperature (PVT) calibration rather than nominal design values. Six heavy-ion species are used, with linear energy transfer (LET) of 4.4–82.06 MeV·cm2/mg, and irradiation data are processed through a five-stage procedure to remove terminal output-stage single-event transients (SETs) and retain genuine bit-cell upsets. All cross-sections are normalized per logic bit (one complete instance) rather than per storage cell. At the highest LET, the DCLR-TMR-DFF achieves the lowest cross-section of 8.23 × 10−10 cm2/bit, approximately 1/145 and 1/27 of the BL-DFF and TMR-DFF cross-sections, respectively; the DF-TMR-DFF cross-sections decrease from 1.58 × 10−8 to 2.06 × 10−9 cm2/bit as the filtering windows widen. The proposed analytical model shows that which of the DF-TMR-DFF and the DCLR-TMR-DFF has the lower per-bit VersaTile overhead depends on the delay-stage count relative to the combinational-to-sequential resource ratio ρ0, with measured per-bit overheads from 11 (BL-DFF) to 37 (DCLR-TMR-DFF) VersaTiles. Post-layout static timing analysis (STA) of standalone projects gives maximum frequencies of 59.034, 52.384, and 43.092 MHz for BL-DFF, TMR-DFF, and DCLR-TMR-DFF, and 40.827–32.083 MHz for the DF-TMR-DFF variants, whose radiation-hardness gain comes at the expense of timing performance. No structure is optimal across all three dimensions, and trade-offs are required in design. A four-tier engineering selection boundary is established for 130 nm ProASIC3 space circuits. All TMR-based structures share an inherent single-point vulnerability at the terminal three-input majority voter.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Electronics
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics15225390
Primary Topic
Radiation Effects in Electronics
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Quantitative Trade-Off Evaluation of Hardened DFFs in 130 nm ProASIC3 Flash-Based FPGAs Under Wide-LET Heavy-Ion Irradiation

Danfeng Qiu, 于宗光, Xin Chen, Daiyin Zhu et al.
Electronics
Radiation Effects in Electronics
article

Quantitative Trade-Off Evaluation of Hardened DFFs in 130 nm ProASIC3 Flash-Based FPGAs Under Wide-LET Heavy-Ion Irradiation

Danfeng Qiu, 于宗光, Xin Chen, Daiyin Zhu, Jinlong Ma, Wenxun Wei, Weike Liu
article en

Abstract

Single-event upset (SEU) hardening of native D flip-flops (DFFs) in flash-based field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) lacks unified experimental conditions and quantitative selection criteria; this work implements six DFF structures on one and the same A3PE3000 chip as identical dual 243-bit shift-register test chains. These include an unhardened baseline DFF (BL-DFF), a conventional triple-modular-redundancy DFF (TMR-DFF), three delay-filtering TMR-DFF variants (DF-TMR-DFF), and one dual-path combinational-logic-replica TMR-DFF (DCLR-TMR-DFF). Realized DF-TMR-DFF filtering windows are set by on-chip process–voltage–temperature (PVT) calibration rather than nominal design values. Six heavy-ion species are used, with linear energy transfer (LET) of 4.4–82.06 MeV·cm2/mg, and irradiation data are processed through a five-stage procedure to remove terminal output-stage single-event transients (SETs) and retain genuine bit-cell upsets. All cross-sections are normalized per logic bit (one complete instance) rather than per storage cell. At the highest LET, the DCLR-TMR-DFF achieves the lowest cross-section of 8.23 × 10−10 cm2/bit, approximately 1/145 and 1/27 of the BL-DFF and TMR-DFF cross-sections, respectively; the DF-TMR-DFF cross-sections decrease from 1.58 × 10−8 to 2.06 × 10−9 cm2/bit as the filtering windows widen. The proposed analytical model shows that which of the DF-TMR-DFF and the DCLR-TMR-DFF has the lower per-bit VersaTile overhead depends on the delay-stage count relative to the combinational-to-sequential resource ratio ρ0, with measured per-bit overheads from 11 (BL-DFF) to 37 (DCLR-TMR-DFF) VersaTiles. Post-layout static timing analysis (STA) of standalone projects gives maximum frequencies of 59.034, 52.384, and 43.092 MHz for BL-DFF, TMR-DFF, and DCLR-TMR-DFF, and 40.827–32.083 MHz for the DF-TMR-DFF variants, whose radiation-hardness gain comes at the expense of timing performance. No structure is optimal across all three dimensions, and trade-offs are required in design. A four-tier engineering selection boundary is established for 130 nm ProASIC3 space circuits. All TMR-based structures share an inherent single-point vulnerability at the terminal three-input majority voter.

ElectronicsVol. 15(22)
China Electronics Technology Group Corporation (CN), Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics (CN)
Radiation Effects in Electronics
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon