Simulation Credibility in Solar-Cell Research: Validation Gaps, Parameter Realism, and a Reviewer-Oriented Framework

Solar-cell simulation is now routinely used to propose new device architectures, passivation routes and high-efficiency designs, yet the credibility of many simulation-based claims remains difficult to judge. A fitted J–V curve or an optimized power-conversion efficiency is often treated as validation, even when key assumptions—defect densities, contact barriers, recombination pathways, optical constants, ion motion, solver settings and fitted parameters—are weakly traceable. This review addresses that gap by treating simulation credibility itself as the object of analysis. Rather than ranking software packages or summarizing optimization trends, it reframes the problem around a more consequential issue: the evidence required for a solar-cell simulation to support a scientific claim. Evidence is synthesized across crystalline silicon, CdTe, CIGS, kesterite, perovskite, organic, dye-sensitized and tandem photovoltaics through six lenses: tool–physics fitness, parameter provenance, validation depth, identifiability and uncertainty, reproducible reporting, and benchmark consistency. The selected examples illustrate how simulated performance claims can exceed the evidence supplied to defend them; this purposive review does not estimate the frequency of such practice. To address this gap, the review develops a claim-specific credibility framework that separates exploratory screening, calibrated reproduction, validated explanation and predictive modelling. It further proposes reviewer-oriented requirements for traceable inputs, multi-observable validation, uncertainty-aware outputs, FAIR-style reporting, benchmark-device packages and a Simulation Credibility Index. The central message is that credible simulation should be judged by the strength of its evidence chain, not by the software name, curve-fit quality or predicted efficiency alone. The SCI is an optional ordinal evidence summary, not a probability or acceptance threshold; critical deficiencies override its mean. Quantitative assessment procedures and four documentary applications make the workflow inspectable, while improved peer-review agreement remains untested.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Semiconductor Science and Technology
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6641/aec475
Primary Topic
Silicon and Solar Cell Technologies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Simulation Credibility in Solar-Cell Research: Validation Gaps, Parameter Realism, and a Reviewer-Oriented Framework

Aimal Daud Khan, Adnan Daud Khan
Semiconductor Science and Technology
Silicon and Solar Cell Technologies
article

Simulation Credibility in Solar-Cell Research: Validation Gaps, Parameter Realism, and a Reviewer-Oriented Framework

Aimal Daud Khan, Adnan Daud Khan
article en

Abstract

Solar-cell simulation is now routinely used to propose new device architectures, passivation routes and high-efficiency designs, yet the credibility of many simulation-based claims remains difficult to judge. A fitted J–V curve or an optimized power-conversion efficiency is often treated as validation, even when key assumptions—defect densities, contact barriers, recombination pathways, optical constants, ion motion, solver settings and fitted parameters—are weakly traceable. This review addresses that gap by treating simulation credibility itself as the object of analysis. Rather than ranking software packages or summarizing optimization trends, it reframes the problem around a more consequential issue: the evidence required for a solar-cell simulation to support a scientific claim. Evidence is synthesized across crystalline silicon, CdTe, CIGS, kesterite, perovskite, organic, dye-sensitized and tandem photovoltaics through six lenses: tool–physics fitness, parameter provenance, validation depth, identifiability and uncertainty, reproducible reporting, and benchmark consistency. The selected examples illustrate how simulated performance claims can exceed the evidence supplied to defend them; this purposive review does not estimate the frequency of such practice. To address this gap, the review develops a claim-specific credibility framework that separates exploratory screening, calibrated reproduction, validated explanation and predictive modelling. It further proposes reviewer-oriented requirements for traceable inputs, multi-observable validation, uncertainty-aware outputs, FAIR-style reporting, benchmark-device packages and a Simulation Credibility Index. The central message is that credible simulation should be judged by the strength of its evidence chain, not by the software name, curve-fit quality or predicted efficiency alone. The SCI is an optional ordinal evidence summary, not a probability or acceptance threshold; critical deficiencies override its mean. Quantitative assessment procedures and four documentary applications make the workflow inspectable, while improved peer-review agreement remains untested.

Semiconductor Science and Technology
University of Engineering and Technology Peshawar (PK)
Silicon and Solar Cell Technologies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon