Electricity Intensity and Co₂e Emission Performance in Paper Production: Benchmarking and Decomposition Analysis of an Industrial Plant in Türkiye

The pulp and paper industry is characterized by substantial energy and resource requirements, making improvements in process efficiency important for reducing environmental impacts. This study evaluates the electricity- and process-related performance of an anonymized paper-production facility in Türkiye through an integrated benchmarking and decomposition framework. Plant-level data were used to quantify electricity intensity, electricity-related CO₂e emission intensity, recycled-pulp utilization, steam utilization, and wastewater generation. The facility was evaluated against a product-matched European reference for recycled-fibre (RCF) mills without deinking producing packaging paper, an industrial reference from Türkiye, and broader sector-level estimates for Türkiye, Europe, and the United States. The analyzed plant exhibited an electricity intensity of 320 kWh/ton, approximately 8.6% below the lower boundary and 28.9% below the upper boundary of the product-matched European reference range of 350–450 kWh/ton. Its electricity-related CO₂e emission intensity was approximately 141 kg CO₂e/ton. When the product-matched European electricity-intensity range was combined with the European grid emission factor of 0.251 kg CO₂e/kWh, the corresponding illustrative emission-intensity range was approximately 88–113 kg CO₂e/ton. Decomposition analysis showed that the lower electricity intensity of the analyzed plant reduced emissions by approximately 13–57 kg CO₂e/ton relative to the product-matched European reference, whereas the higher Turkish grid emission factor increased them by approximately 67–86 kg CO₂e/ton, resulting in a net increase of approximately 29–54 kg CO₂e/ton. Relative to the estimated Türkiye sector-level reference, the approximately 242 kg CO₂e/ton reduction was entirely attributable to lower electricity intensity because both systems shared the same grid emission factor. Process assessment further indicated an 85% recycled-pulp ratio and a 64.3% steam-utilization ratio. Overall, the results demonstrate that comparatively low plant-level electricity consumption does not necessarily result in lower electricity-related CO₂e emissions when the electricity supply has a higher carbon intensity. The proposed framework provides a practical approach for distinguishing plant-level electricity-efficiency effects from electricity-grid carbon-intensity effects in paper-production benchmarking.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11037857/v1
Primary Topic
Environmental Impact and Sustainability
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Electricity Intensity and Co₂e Emission Performance in Paper Production: Benchmarking and Decomposition Analysis of an Industrial Plant in Türkiye

Esma Cetinkaya, Ahmet Muharrem GÖRÜNMEZ
Research Square
Environmental Impact and Sustainability
preprint

Electricity Intensity and Co₂e Emission Performance in Paper Production: Benchmarking and Decomposition Analysis of an Industrial Plant in Türkiye

Esma Cetinkaya, Ahmet Muharrem GÖRÜNMEZ
preprint en

Abstract

The pulp and paper industry is characterized by substantial energy and resource requirements, making improvements in process efficiency important for reducing environmental impacts. This study evaluates the electricity- and process-related performance of an anonymized paper-production facility in Türkiye through an integrated benchmarking and decomposition framework. Plant-level data were used to quantify electricity intensity, electricity-related CO₂e emission intensity, recycled-pulp utilization, steam utilization, and wastewater generation. The facility was evaluated against a product-matched European reference for recycled-fibre (RCF) mills without deinking producing packaging paper, an industrial reference from Türkiye, and broader sector-level estimates for Türkiye, Europe, and the United States. The analyzed plant exhibited an electricity intensity of 320 kWh/ton, approximately 8.6% below the lower boundary and 28.9% below the upper boundary of the product-matched European reference range of 350–450 kWh/ton. Its electricity-related CO₂e emission intensity was approximately 141 kg CO₂e/ton. When the product-matched European electricity-intensity range was combined with the European grid emission factor of 0.251 kg CO₂e/kWh, the corresponding illustrative emission-intensity range was approximately 88–113 kg CO₂e/ton. Decomposition analysis showed that the lower electricity intensity of the analyzed plant reduced emissions by approximately 13–57 kg CO₂e/ton relative to the product-matched European reference, whereas the higher Turkish grid emission factor increased them by approximately 67–86 kg CO₂e/ton, resulting in a net increase of approximately 29–54 kg CO₂e/ton. Relative to the estimated Türkiye sector-level reference, the approximately 242 kg CO₂e/ton reduction was entirely attributable to lower electricity intensity because both systems shared the same grid emission factor. Process assessment further indicated an 85% recycled-pulp ratio and a 64.3% steam-utilization ratio. Overall, the results demonstrate that comparatively low plant-level electricity consumption does not necessarily result in lower electricity-related CO₂e emissions when the electricity supply has a higher carbon intensity. The proposed framework provides a practical approach for distinguishing plant-level electricity-efficiency effects from electricity-grid carbon-intensity effects in paper-production benchmarking.

Research Square
Kahramanmaraş Sütçü İmam University (TR)
Environmental Impact and Sustainability
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon