How representative is flora rescue? A 15-year analysis of species composition in iron ore mining in the Brazilian Amazon and the gap for endemic and rare species conservation

Mitigation-driven plant translocations are widely used during environmental licensing, yet their effectiveness in protecting biodiversity remains uncertain. We evaluated a large-scale flora rescue and reintroduction program associated with iron ore and manganese mining on Amazonian rock outcrops ( canga ), Carajás, Brazil. Using data from the Annual Environmental Performance Reports (RADA) from 2010–2024, we assessed taxonomic uncertainty, species, functional and phylogenetic diversity, habit-based representation, species abundance and temporal trends relative to the reference canga flora. The database comprised 351,594 rescue records assigned to 347 registered taxonomic names, of which 277 (79.9%) were retained as accepted names. The validated assemblage shared 107 species with the 1,045-species reference flora (10.24% coverage; Jaccard = 0.0881). Restricting the reference flora to the 429 species documented for the two mined plateaus raised coverage to 14.5% but similarity was nearly unchanged (Jaccard = 0.0963). Among the 99 shared seed-plant species, coverage-standardized richness did not differ from the reference (95.7 vs 99.0 species), and null models showed that registered assemblages held less phylogenetic diversity than expected from their richness, which reflects rescue concentration in a few predominantly epiphytic clades. Abundance was highly uneven, with 37 species accounting for ~ 90% of validated individuals. Rescue yield per suppressed hectare increased over time, and was decoupled from vegetation suppressed area. Because the records do not support inference on post-translocation persistence, these results characterize representativeness rather than conservation outcomes. Embedding reference-based targets and independent verification of post-translocation performance into licensing conditions would allow programs to demonstrate ecological rather than documentary performance.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11580645/v1
Primary Topic
Ecology and Vegetation Dynamics Studies
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

How representative is flora rescue? A 15-year analysis of species composition in iron ore mining in the Brazilian Amazon and the gap for endemic and rare species conservation

Fernando A. O. Silveira, Fernando M. G. Santos
Research Square
Ecology and Vegetation Dynamics Studies
preprint

How representative is flora rescue? A 15-year analysis of species composition in iron ore mining in the Brazilian Amazon and the gap for endemic and rare species conservation

Fernando A. O. Silveira, Fernando M. G. Santos
preprint en

Abstract

Mitigation-driven plant translocations are widely used during environmental licensing, yet their effectiveness in protecting biodiversity remains uncertain. We evaluated a large-scale flora rescue and reintroduction program associated with iron ore and manganese mining on Amazonian rock outcrops ( canga ), Carajás, Brazil. Using data from the Annual Environmental Performance Reports (RADA) from 2010–2024, we assessed taxonomic uncertainty, species, functional and phylogenetic diversity, habit-based representation, species abundance and temporal trends relative to the reference canga flora. The database comprised 351,594 rescue records assigned to 347 registered taxonomic names, of which 277 (79.9%) were retained as accepted names. The validated assemblage shared 107 species with the 1,045-species reference flora (10.24% coverage; Jaccard = 0.0881). Restricting the reference flora to the 429 species documented for the two mined plateaus raised coverage to 14.5% but similarity was nearly unchanged (Jaccard = 0.0963). Among the 99 shared seed-plant species, coverage-standardized richness did not differ from the reference (95.7 vs 99.0 species), and null models showed that registered assemblages held less phylogenetic diversity than expected from their richness, which reflects rescue concentration in a few predominantly epiphytic clades. Abundance was highly uneven, with 37 species accounting for ~ 90% of validated individuals. Rescue yield per suppressed hectare increased over time, and was decoupled from vegetation suppressed area. Because the records do not support inference on post-translocation persistence, these results characterize representativeness rather than conservation outcomes. Embedding reference-based targets and independent verification of post-translocation performance into licensing conditions would allow programs to demonstrate ecological rather than documentary performance.

Research Square
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (BR)
Ecology and Vegetation Dynamics Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon