Conditioned connectomes outperform the standard correlation kernel for predicting cognition in an independent cohort

Connectome-based cognition predictions are scored differently across papers. We re-scored a public Human Connectome Project benchmark (753 subjects, six fMRI modalities, 60 family-aware splits) as its authors do, with a public age band in place of exact age, and evaluated a kernel ridge pipeline that conditions each subject's connectome and filters the between-subject kernel's spectrum. With fixed settings it reached r = 0.7215, against 0.6779 for the benchmark paper's best model and 0.6798 for our re-run of its kernel (corrected t = 3.23). This margin is transductive: the filter uses all subjects' unlabelled features, helps only after conditioning, and gives no significant gain fitted on training subjects alone; without it, the difference was not significant. On 263 HCP subjects outside the benchmark, most used in development, a pre-registered comparison favoured the filtered pipeline, computed with them present, over the benchmark's kernel by 0.064 (95% interval 0.030 to 0.099). In an independent cohort never used in development (1,290 adults aged 36 to 89, resting state), the conditioned connectome, fitted on training subjects only, beat the benchmark's kernel as pre-registered (r = 0.5861 against 0.5257; corrected t = 5.47); the filter added nothing there. Against a frozen fMRI foundation model on identical splits, the unfiltered pipeline was ahead in 7 of 8 settings, significantly on resting state (corrected t = 3.88), held-out subjects and ABIDE autism diagnosis, and nominally in AOMIC. Of 18 pre-registered single-decision contrasts, 9 were met, 5 by counting repeats. Two scoring choices each reversed a method ordering.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11794795/v1
Primary Topic
Functional Brain Connectivity Studies
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Conditioned connectomes outperform the standard correlation kernel for predicting cognition in an independent cohort

Chulmin Pyo
Research Square
Functional Brain Connectivity Studies
preprint

Conditioned connectomes outperform the standard correlation kernel for predicting cognition in an independent cohort

Chulmin Pyo
preprint en

Abstract

Connectome-based cognition predictions are scored differently across papers. We re-scored a public Human Connectome Project benchmark (753 subjects, six fMRI modalities, 60 family-aware splits) as its authors do, with a public age band in place of exact age, and evaluated a kernel ridge pipeline that conditions each subject's connectome and filters the between-subject kernel's spectrum. With fixed settings it reached r = 0.7215, against 0.6779 for the benchmark paper's best model and 0.6798 for our re-run of its kernel (corrected t = 3.23). This margin is transductive: the filter uses all subjects' unlabelled features, helps only after conditioning, and gives no significant gain fitted on training subjects alone; without it, the difference was not significant. On 263 HCP subjects outside the benchmark, most used in development, a pre-registered comparison favoured the filtered pipeline, computed with them present, over the benchmark's kernel by 0.064 (95% interval 0.030 to 0.099). In an independent cohort never used in development (1,290 adults aged 36 to 89, resting state), the conditioned connectome, fitted on training subjects only, beat the benchmark's kernel as pre-registered (r = 0.5861 against 0.5257; corrected t = 5.47); the filter added nothing there. Against a frozen fMRI foundation model on identical splits, the unfiltered pipeline was ahead in 7 of 8 settings, significantly on resting state (corrected t = 3.88), held-out subjects and ABIDE autism diagnosis, and nominally in AOMIC. Of 18 pre-registered single-decision contrasts, 9 were met, 5 by counting repeats. Two scoring choices each reversed a method ordering.

Research Square
Functional Brain Connectivity Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon