Commons Sense: Why Denying Res Communis Destabilizes Legal Protections for Space Assets

Modern United States space policy explicitly rejects the characterization of outer space as a “global commons” or res communis. Proponents of this shift contend that avoiding these communal terms is necessary to protect and further private commercial resource extraction and permanent human settlement. This article demonstrates that such a premise is both historically revisionist and legally counterproductive. A rigorous examination of the Outer Space Treaty’s travaux préparatoires, the 1967 Senate ratification record, and five decades of consistent bipartisan executive practice through early 2020 proves that the United States originally engineered and continuously upheld the Treaty with the explicit understanding that it codified the res omnium communis character of space. By conflating classical res communis with the redistributive “common heritage of mankind” regime of the failed Moon Agreement, recent executive actions have alienated international partners, catalyzed multilateral regulatory pushback at the United Nations, and functioned as legal placebos that do nothing to strengthen American operational capabilities. Instead, this article argues that by declaring outer space is not a global commons governed by customary international law, the United States has introduced profound systemic instability into the regime, fundamentally weakening the legal protections for both domestic commercial and national security assets. Declassified primary documents from the 1950s reveal that Washington originally manufactured the res communis framework as a matter of raw national survival to legalize orbital reconnaissance overflight. Absent this protective communal shroud, foreign adversaries are handed the exact jurisprudential architecture to bypass the absolute sovereignty bar of OST Article II, asserting expansive claims to exclusive zones via maritime-style “Orbital Economic Zones.” Using historical precedents of subthreshold, grey-zone electronic warfare, this paper demonstrates how the non-commons doctrine permits adversaries to reframe hostile interferences into defensible domestic enforcement actions under the color of law, upending the dual mandates for due regard and against harmful interference under OST Article IX. Finally, to remedy international space law’s chronic definitional deficit, this article proposes a consensus-ready, Lockean definition of res communis for adoption by the United States and its Artemis Accords partners—one that reconciles military freedom of action, private property rights in extracted resources, and localized Article IX safety zones without inviting expansive territorial enclosure.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24382529
Primary Topic
Space exploration and regulation
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Commons Sense: Why Denying Res Communis Destabilizes Legal Protections for Space Assets

Thomas Gangale
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Space exploration and regulation
preprint

Commons Sense: Why Denying Res Communis Destabilizes Legal Protections for Space Assets

Thomas Gangale
preprint en

Abstract

Modern United States space policy explicitly rejects the characterization of outer space as a “global commons” or res communis. Proponents of this shift contend that avoiding these communal terms is necessary to protect and further private commercial resource extraction and permanent human settlement. This article demonstrates that such a premise is both historically revisionist and legally counterproductive. A rigorous examination of the Outer Space Treaty’s travaux préparatoires, the 1967 Senate ratification record, and five decades of consistent bipartisan executive practice through early 2020 proves that the United States originally engineered and continuously upheld the Treaty with the explicit understanding that it codified the res omnium communis character of space. By conflating classical res communis with the redistributive “common heritage of mankind” regime of the failed Moon Agreement, recent executive actions have alienated international partners, catalyzed multilateral regulatory pushback at the United Nations, and functioned as legal placebos that do nothing to strengthen American operational capabilities. Instead, this article argues that by declaring outer space is not a global commons governed by customary international law, the United States has introduced profound systemic instability into the regime, fundamentally weakening the legal protections for both domestic commercial and national security assets. Declassified primary documents from the 1950s reveal that Washington originally manufactured the res communis framework as a matter of raw national survival to legalize orbital reconnaissance overflight. Absent this protective communal shroud, foreign adversaries are handed the exact jurisprudential architecture to bypass the absolute sovereignty bar of OST Article II, asserting expansive claims to exclusive zones via maritime-style “Orbital Economic Zones.” Using historical precedents of subthreshold, grey-zone electronic warfare, this paper demonstrates how the non-commons doctrine permits adversaries to reframe hostile interferences into defensible domestic enforcement actions under the color of law, upending the dual mandates for due regard and against harmful interference under OST Article IX. Finally, to remedy international space law’s chronic definitional deficit, this article proposes a consensus-ready, Lockean definition of res communis for adoption by the United States and its Artemis Accords partners—one that reconciles military freedom of action, private property rights in extracted resources, and localized Article IX safety zones without inviting expansive territorial enclosure.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Space exploration and regulation
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon