UNDERSTANDING BOARD LEADERSHIP COMPETENCIES IN VOLUNTEER-LED NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS IN THE NORTHEAST UNITED STATES: A PHENOMENOLOGICAL STUDY
Board leadership competencies are important to the governance of volunteer-led nonprofit organizations, particularly where volunteer board members perform governance and organizational responsibilities with limited or no paid staff support. Current research provides limited insight into how volunteer board members in small to midsize volunteer-led nonprofit organizations understand the leadership competencies associated with nonprofit governance. This qualitative phenomenological study explored how volunteer board leaders of small to midsize nonprofits in the Northeast United States understood and enacted the competencies central to effective governance, based on their firsthand accounts of board service. The study addressed two research questions: What are the lived experiences of board members in volunteer-led nonprofit organizations in the Northeast United States regarding board leadership competencies in nonprofit governance? How do board members in volunteer-led nonprofit organizations perceive their roles and responsibilities within the governance structure? Ten volunteer board members volunteered to participate in this study, were recruited through criterion-based sampling, and participated in semi-structured interviews. Participants represented variation in board roles, organizational missions, and professional backgrounds. Interview data were analyzed using a transcendental phenomenological approach that included bracketing, horizontalization, reduction and elimination, identification of invariant constituents, theme development, and individual and composite textural and structural descriptions. Findings indicated that participants experienced effective volunteer board leadership as mission-centered stewardship requiring role clarity, competency development, shared responsibility, ethical accountability, relational trust, and adaptability. Participants developed leadership competencies through professional experience, experiential learning, peer relationships, mentoring, and formal or informal preparation. Their experiences also revealed challenges associated with inadequate onboarding, role ambiguity, unequal distribution of work, limited organizational capacity, interpersonal and political conflict, and the competing demands placed on volunteers. Collectively, the findings indicated that effective governance in volunteer-led nonprofit organizations depended not solely on individual board-member competency, but also on organizational structures and relationships that enabled volunteers to mobilize their knowledge, time, experience, and social resources in support of the mission. The findings may inform board recruitment, orientation, leadership development, succession planning, governance practices, and strategies for sustaining effective volunteer board leadership.
Authors
- Adrian Tiffany-Scott Plummer (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0000-8064-7741)
Institutions
- Capella University (US)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24371710
- Primary Topic
- Nonprofit Sector and Volunteering
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00