What Is an Economic Class? Ontological Foundations of Class in Plural Societies

Background. Economic class is among the most frequently invoked and least consistently defined concepts in economics, sociology and public policy. Researchers variously treat class as a property relation, a labour-market situation, an income band, a bundle of capitals or a collective identity, and these choices change who is counted as poor, middle class or elite. Objective. This paper asks what an economic class is : under what conditions a set of individuals or households can justifiably be said to share a class position, and how that position differs from adjacent constructs in societies divided by ethnicity, religion, caste, gender, language and region. Approach. The paper combines critical-realist social ontology with a structured comparison of Marxian, Weberian, institutional, stratification, Bourdieusian, feminist, intersectional and capability approaches. It then develops a formal framework, a classification rule and a measurement design, illustrated with Pakistan and with India, South Africa and Malaysia as contrasting cases. Argument. Economic class is defined as a durable position within relations of asset control, livelihood dependence and employment authority, constituted by institutions and consequential for life chances. Bargaining power and institutional access are treated as causal mechanisms; income level and economic security are treated as consequences and indicators. Class position does not require consciousness, but class formation does. Contribution. The paper offers (a) explicit existence conditions for claiming that a class exists, (b) a six-component position vector separating constitutive, mechanistic and indicator dimensions, (c) a provisional eight-category relational typology with a transparent priority rule, (d) an evaluation of an existing eight-band income classification for Pakistan, and (e) ten propositions separating definitions, mechanisms and testable hypotheses. Limitations. The typology is provisional; illustrative figures use clearly labelled synthetic data, and no causal estimates are reported.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11775771/v1
Primary Topic
Income, Poverty, and Inequality
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

What Is an Economic Class? Ontological Foundations of Class in Plural Societies

Muhmmad Muqeem Islam Muqeem
Research Square
Income, Poverty, and Inequality
preprint

What Is an Economic Class? Ontological Foundations of Class in Plural Societies

Muhmmad Muqeem Islam Muqeem
preprint en

Abstract

Background. Economic class is among the most frequently invoked and least consistently defined concepts in economics, sociology and public policy. Researchers variously treat class as a property relation, a labour-market situation, an income band, a bundle of capitals or a collective identity, and these choices change who is counted as poor, middle class or elite. Objective. This paper asks what an economic class is : under what conditions a set of individuals or households can justifiably be said to share a class position, and how that position differs from adjacent constructs in societies divided by ethnicity, religion, caste, gender, language and region. Approach. The paper combines critical-realist social ontology with a structured comparison of Marxian, Weberian, institutional, stratification, Bourdieusian, feminist, intersectional and capability approaches. It then develops a formal framework, a classification rule and a measurement design, illustrated with Pakistan and with India, South Africa and Malaysia as contrasting cases. Argument. Economic class is defined as a durable position within relations of asset control, livelihood dependence and employment authority, constituted by institutions and consequential for life chances. Bargaining power and institutional access are treated as causal mechanisms; income level and economic security are treated as consequences and indicators. Class position does not require consciousness, but class formation does. Contribution. The paper offers (a) explicit existence conditions for claiming that a class exists, (b) a six-component position vector separating constitutive, mechanistic and indicator dimensions, (c) a provisional eight-category relational typology with a transparent priority rule, (d) an evaluation of an existing eight-band income classification for Pakistan, and (e) ten propositions separating definitions, mechanisms and testable hypotheses. Limitations. The typology is provisional; illustrative figures use clearly labelled synthetic data, and no causal estimates are reported.

Research Square
National School of Public Policy (PK)
Income, Poverty, and Inequality
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon