Position more than place: a multicentric qualitative study of healthcare access among urban working women in five Indian cities

Background Urban women in paid employment are commonly taken to be the advantaged segment of India’s female workforce: closer to facilities, better educated and more likely to be insured. Existing qualitative evidence on their healthcare access is almost entirely single-site, leaving unresolved whether a documented barrier reflects the setting or the women’s own position. Methods We interviewed 65 working women in five Indian cities across five states (Udupi 10, Palakkad 19, Ahmedabad 13, Kanyakumari 12, Mumbai 11), in seven languages, using a common guide and snowball recruitment. The sample is predominantly formally employed, though it includes women with no formal schooling, earnings as low as ₹6,000 a month, and no insurance. Interviews were coded inductively and independently at each site with no shared codebook; frameworks were harmonised post hoc and examined for cross-site convergence. Results Of six themes identified, five recurred at all five sites — occupational structure and workplace demands, domestic and caregiving burden, economic capacity and insurance, health-system access, and deprioritisation of personal care — and perceived quality and trust at four. The linking mechanism was time poverty: paid and unpaid work together consumed the hours in which care could be sought. Financial protection was bounded rather than binary: eighteen of 65 held no insurance, and among the insured cover was often restricted to the employee, to hospitalisation, or withdrawn above an income ceiling. Insurance tracked employment formality rather than city, income or proximity, and was decoupled from occupational standing: half the uninsured at Kanyakumari were teachers or assistant professors. Conclusions The same barriers recurred across five socioculturally and linguistically distinct cities under independent site-level coding. They are bounded to a predominantly formally employed sample recruited by referral in five southern and western states, and are not representative of urban working women in India. Within those bounds: if women in this comparatively protected position encounter these constraints, women in more precarious employment are unlikely to encounter fewer. Workplace provision, financial protection beyond hospitalisation and beyond the individual employee, and redistribution of unpaid care warrant examination in representative samples.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
International Journal for Equity in Health
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12939-026-03122-4
Primary Topic
Public Health and Social Inequalities
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Position more than place: a multicentric qualitative study of healthcare access among urban working women in five Indian cities

Selim Jahangir, Rajesh Kamath, Shamitha Shetty. R, Shivani Muneeswaran et al.
International Journal for Equity in Health
Public Health and Social Inequalities
article

Position more than place: a multicentric qualitative study of healthcare access among urban working women in five Indian cities

Selim Jahangir, Rajesh Kamath, Shamitha Shetty. R, Shivani Muneeswaran, Jay Bharti, J. Athira, Niranjan Jacob
article en

Abstract

Background Urban women in paid employment are commonly taken to be the advantaged segment of India’s female workforce: closer to facilities, better educated and more likely to be insured. Existing qualitative evidence on their healthcare access is almost entirely single-site, leaving unresolved whether a documented barrier reflects the setting or the women’s own position. Methods We interviewed 65 working women in five Indian cities across five states (Udupi 10, Palakkad 19, Ahmedabad 13, Kanyakumari 12, Mumbai 11), in seven languages, using a common guide and snowball recruitment. The sample is predominantly formally employed, though it includes women with no formal schooling, earnings as low as ₹6,000 a month, and no insurance. Interviews were coded inductively and independently at each site with no shared codebook; frameworks were harmonised post hoc and examined for cross-site convergence. Results Of six themes identified, five recurred at all five sites — occupational structure and workplace demands, domestic and caregiving burden, economic capacity and insurance, health-system access, and deprioritisation of personal care — and perceived quality and trust at four. The linking mechanism was time poverty: paid and unpaid work together consumed the hours in which care could be sought. Financial protection was bounded rather than binary: eighteen of 65 held no insurance, and among the insured cover was often restricted to the employee, to hospitalisation, or withdrawn above an income ceiling. Insurance tracked employment formality rather than city, income or proximity, and was decoupled from occupational standing: half the uninsured at Kanyakumari were teachers or assistant professors. Conclusions The same barriers recurred across five socioculturally and linguistically distinct cities under independent site-level coding. They are bounded to a predominantly formally employed sample recruited by referral in five southern and western states, and are not representative of urban working women in India. Within those bounds: if women in this comparatively protected position encounter these constraints, women in more precarious employment are unlikely to encounter fewer. Workplace provision, financial protection beyond hospitalisation and beyond the individual employee, and redistribution of unpaid care warrant examination in representative samples.

International Journal for Equity in Health
Public Health and Social Inequalities
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon