Paper III — Montessori Epistemic Pedagogy & Capacity-Proportional Curriculum Scaling
Small and mid-scale open-weight language models (<= 9B parameters) suffer from three coupled failure modes under multi-turn interaction: (1) epistemic confabulation on zero-evidence fabricated entities, (2) sycophantic collapse ("I apologize for the confusion") when challenged by adversarial social pressure ("Are you sure?") on true propositions, and (3) in-context momentum rigidity, where long conversational histories or aggressive supervised fine-tuning (SFT) lock the model into repetitive attractors. While recent literature has explored Piagetian developmental curricula, Vygotskian scaffolding, and embodied sensorimotor bootstrapping for robotics, no prior work has formalized Maria Montessori's pedagogical architecture—specifically Isolation of a Single Epistemic Difficulty, Concrete-to-Abstract Proposition Grounding, Intrinsic Control of Error, and the Three-Period Naming Lesson—as a mathematical post-training and memory-harness methodology for language model epistemic honesty. In Phase I of this study, we implement and evaluate Montessori Epistemic Pedagogy on a 32-layer hybrid Gated-DeltaNet / Full-Attention spine (MiniMinX-2.6B, d_model=2048, upper-half L16-L31 selective plasticity, paired with the event-gated Sovereign Titan Crown, query-matched TitanGraphDB, and a 3-Turn Rolling Context Window). We report five core empirical findings: 1. The Capacity-Proportional Loss Band Law & Negative-Result Post-Mortem: Driving a 2.6B model to near-zero cross-entropy loss (L_SFT in [0.0397, 0.0554]) on a 6-token refusal template (checkpoint 2bb253bf) or internal memory-routing tags ([TitanGraphDB], checkpoint 4425c1ae) collapses generation diversity into absorbing phrase loops and metadata reification. Preserving a capacity-proportional gentle SFT loss floor (L_SFT = 0.7777) followed by stop-anchored Direct Preference Optimization (margin = +6.9872, 9/9 wins, checkpoint 6df8c7e2) eliminates phrase looping while achieving 10/10 on blind multi-turn stress tests. 2. Proposition-Bound Certainty vs. Social-Pressure Reflex (6df8c7e2): Training on 8 minimal Montessori contrast pairs where the exact same challenge ("Are you sure?") follows a grounded truth vs. an overstatement binds certainty to the truth value of the prior proposition rather than the surface prompt trigger, enabling spontaneous epistemic self-correction without sycophantic capitulation. 3. Cross-Scale Triad & Four-Reviewer Audited 5-Axis Calibration (2.6B vs. 4B vs. 9B): Benchmarking MiniMinX-2.6B against Qwen3.5-4B-heretic and Qwen3.5-9B-heretic demonstrates that MiniMinX-2.6B outperforms 4B (100% vs. 33.3%) on single-entity zero-evidence traps (Olpress, Solvex-9, Velkorin-14) and recovers 3/3 evicted facts across a 12-turn rolling-window eviction test where un-gated 4B and 9B (W=3) score 0/4. 4. The Hydraulic "River Spillway" Staged-Compute Regulation (7/7 Bottleneck Recovery): To resolve residual bottlenecks in the narrow 32L x 2048 spine without weight modification, we introduce a two-stage Sluice-Gate compute pass (Stage 1: premise, timestamp, and prerequisite order extraction; Stage 2: regulated final synthesis), recovering 7/7 previously failed multi-hop reasoning and prerequisite-ordering probes and lifting MiniMinX-2.6B's strict 20-probe score from 12/20 (60.0%) to 19/20 (95.0%). 5. Theoretical Synthesis & Phase II 9B Falsification (Minx-Qwen3.5-9B Pure Lossless BF16): We synthesize our findings with recursive harness evolution (AIDE^2, arXiv:2609.26457), Continual Recursive Self-Improvement with Self-Improvement Memory (CRSI + SIM, arXiv:2611.18856), and Tritemporal K-Time governance (10.5281/zenodo.23198458), and demonstrate pure lossless BF16 upper-half Montessori training on a 32-layer Qwen3.5-9B spine (d_model=4096, vision/MTP stripped) on a single 16 GB consumer GPU.
Authors
- Antonia Vasile (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0006-7509-0081)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24382001
- Primary Topic
- Topic Modeling
- Type
- preprint