Different perspectives on scars after autologous breast reconstruction: patient-reported and surgeon-rated outcomes following ELD and DIEP flaps

Background Postoperative scars are an important outcome of autologous breast reconstruction, affecting both the reconstructed breast and flap donor site. This study compared patient-reported and surgeon-rated scar outcomes following extended latissimus dorsi (ELD) and deep inferior epigastric perforator (DIEP) flap reconstruction and explored factors associated with differences in scar perception. Methods Twenty-seven patients who underwent ELD ( n = 12) or DIEP ( n = 15) flap reconstruction were evaluated 1–5 years after reconstruction. Reconstructed-breast and donor-site scars were assessed separately using the Japanese version of the SCAR-Q (SCAR-Q_J) and the Manchester Scar Scale (MSS). Between-group comparisons were supplemented by Mann–Whitney U sensitivity analyses. Direct associations between SCAR-Q_J Appearance and total MSS scores were examined using Spearman's rank correlation, and an exploratory linear regression analysis assessed the potential influence of reconstructed-breast scar location. Results For reconstructed-breast scars, SCAR-Q_J Appearance scores were higher in the ELD group than in the DIEP group (72.42 vs. 61.30, p = 0.028), and this difference remained significant in the Mann–Whitney U sensitivity analysis ( p = 0.033). However, after accounting for scar location in exploratory linear regression, the between-group difference was attenuated and did not reach statistical significance ( p = 0.066). MSS scores did not differ significantly between groups for reconstructed-breast scars. For donor-site scars, SCAR-Q_J scores did not differ significantly, whereas MSS color and total scores were more favorable in the ELD group; these differences remained significant in sensitivity analyses. SCAR-Q_J Appearance and total MSS scores showed a moderate inverse correlation for reconstructed-breast scars (Spearman's ρ = −0.435, p = 0.023), whereas no statistically significant correlation was observed for donor-site scars ( ρ = −0.275, p = 0.165). Conclusion Patient-reported and surgeon-rated scar assessments showed partly differing patterns and were moderately associated for reconstructed-breast scars. Scar location may have contributed to the observed between-group difference in patient-reported breast-scar appearance. The two assessment approaches may therefore provide related but complementary information. When oncologic safety and adequate tissue perfusion are ensured, patient-reported information regarding scar location and visibility may provide additional guidance for collaborative incision planning.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Frontiers in Surgery
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fsurg.2026.1985026
Primary Topic
Breast Implant and Reconstruction
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Different perspectives on scars after autologous breast reconstruction: patient-reported and surgeon-rated outcomes following ELD and DIEP flaps

Hajime Matsumura, Takako Komiya, Miki Fujii, Kazuki Shimada et al.
Frontiers in Surgery
Breast Implant and Reconstruction
article

Different perspectives on scars after autologous breast reconstruction: patient-reported and surgeon-rated outcomes following ELD and DIEP flaps

Hajime Matsumura, Takako Komiya, Miki Fujii, Kazuki Shimada, Mai Hanano, Misa Suzuki, Yuriko tiare Higuchi
article en

Abstract

Background Postoperative scars are an important outcome of autologous breast reconstruction, affecting both the reconstructed breast and flap donor site. This study compared patient-reported and surgeon-rated scar outcomes following extended latissimus dorsi (ELD) and deep inferior epigastric perforator (DIEP) flap reconstruction and explored factors associated with differences in scar perception. Methods Twenty-seven patients who underwent ELD ( n = 12) or DIEP ( n = 15) flap reconstruction were evaluated 1–5 years after reconstruction. Reconstructed-breast and donor-site scars were assessed separately using the Japanese version of the SCAR-Q (SCAR-Q_J) and the Manchester Scar Scale (MSS). Between-group comparisons were supplemented by Mann–Whitney U sensitivity analyses. Direct associations between SCAR-Q_J Appearance and total MSS scores were examined using Spearman's rank correlation, and an exploratory linear regression analysis assessed the potential influence of reconstructed-breast scar location. Results For reconstructed-breast scars, SCAR-Q_J Appearance scores were higher in the ELD group than in the DIEP group (72.42 vs. 61.30, p = 0.028), and this difference remained significant in the Mann–Whitney U sensitivity analysis ( p = 0.033). However, after accounting for scar location in exploratory linear regression, the between-group difference was attenuated and did not reach statistical significance ( p = 0.066). MSS scores did not differ significantly between groups for reconstructed-breast scars. For donor-site scars, SCAR-Q_J scores did not differ significantly, whereas MSS color and total scores were more favorable in the ELD group; these differences remained significant in sensitivity analyses. SCAR-Q_J Appearance and total MSS scores showed a moderate inverse correlation for reconstructed-breast scars (Spearman's ρ = −0.435, p = 0.023), whereas no statistically significant correlation was observed for donor-site scars ( ρ = −0.275, p = 0.165). Conclusion Patient-reported and surgeon-rated scar assessments showed partly differing patterns and were moderately associated for reconstructed-breast scars. Scar location may have contributed to the observed between-group difference in patient-reported breast-scar appearance. The two assessment approaches may therefore provide related but complementary information. When oncologic safety and adequate tissue perfusion are ensured, patient-reported information regarding scar location and visibility may provide additional guidance for collaborative incision planning.

Frontiers in SurgeryVol. 13
Tokyo Medical University (JP)
Breast Implant and Reconstruction
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon