Sensitivity of Water Saturation to Formation Water Resistivity in Argillaceous Sandstone

Formation water resistivity (Rw) is often the most uncertain input in water saturation (Sw) calculations, especially when clean water zones and formation water samples are unavailable. This study measured the sensitivity of Sw to Rw in argillaceous sandstones of the Petani Formation, Central Sumatra Basin, at depths of 1358 and 1359 ft in Well A of Field X. Shale volume was calculated using the Larionov equation of old rocks, effective porosity from shale-corrected neutron density logs, and Sw using the generalized form of the Simandoux equation solved iteratively (a = 1.65; m = 1.8; n = 1.8). Sw was calculated over the Rw range of 0.01–0.40 ohm-m and compared to four reference values, namely Rwa, software Rw, critical Rw, and implicit Rw. Both points have Vsh 0.056–0.072 and effective porosity 0.335–0.345, but Sw shifts from 0.47 to above 1 depending on Rw. Both points only pass the Sw 0.60 cut-off when Rw ≤ 0.062–0.068 ohm-m, about half of Rwa (0.121–0.122 ohm-m). The software Rw (0.335–0.348 ohm-m) yields Sw > 1, while the software Sw can only be recovered with Rw about nine times smaller, a difference not explained by the temperature correction. The prospect status of this interval therefore depends on independent Rw measurements.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Ambidextrous
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.61536/ambidextrous.v4i04.1003
Primary Topic
Hydrocarbon exploration and reservoir analysis
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Sensitivity of Water Saturation to Formation Water Resistivity in Argillaceous Sandstone

Muhammad Alghifari
Ambidextrous
Hydrocarbon exploration and reservoir analysis
article

Sensitivity of Water Saturation to Formation Water Resistivity in Argillaceous Sandstone

Muhammad Alghifari
article en

Abstract

Formation water resistivity (Rw) is often the most uncertain input in water saturation (Sw) calculations, especially when clean water zones and formation water samples are unavailable. This study measured the sensitivity of Sw to Rw in argillaceous sandstones of the Petani Formation, Central Sumatra Basin, at depths of 1358 and 1359 ft in Well A of Field X. Shale volume was calculated using the Larionov equation of old rocks, effective porosity from shale-corrected neutron density logs, and Sw using the generalized form of the Simandoux equation solved iteratively (a = 1.65; m = 1.8; n = 1.8). Sw was calculated over the Rw range of 0.01–0.40 ohm-m and compared to four reference values, namely Rwa, software Rw, critical Rw, and implicit Rw. Both points have Vsh 0.056–0.072 and effective porosity 0.335–0.345, but Sw shifts from 0.47 to above 1 depending on Rw. Both points only pass the Sw 0.60 cut-off when Rw ≤ 0.062–0.068 ohm-m, about half of Rwa (0.121–0.122 ohm-m). The software Rw (0.335–0.348 ohm-m) yields Sw > 1, while the software Sw can only be recovered with Rw about nine times smaller, a difference not explained by the temperature correction. The prospect status of this interval therefore depends on independent Rw measurements.

AmbidextrousVol. 4(04)
Hydrocarbon exploration and reservoir analysis
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon