Beyond Single-Source Rewarding: Adaptive Mutual-Human Rewarding Through Multi-Model Interaction and Human Participation
Reward mechanisms constitute a fundamental component of intelligent systems, reinforcement learning, preference alignment, autonomous agents, and the development of increasingly capable artificial intelligence. Existing research has investigated reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF), reinforcement learning from AI feedback (RLAIF), preference-based learning, reward modeling, self-rewarding language models, and reward interactions among multiple agents. These approaches demonstrate that rewards can originate from different sources and that both human judgments and artificial intelligence evaluations can contribute to model optimization. However, a general mechanism-independent architecture that explicitly integrates mutual rewarding among multiple heterogeneous large language models with independent human rewarding, while adaptively switching between these reward sources according to changing operational conditions, remains insufficiently formalized. This paper introduces Adaptive Mutual-Human Rewarding (AMHR) as a function-specific extension of the Universal Mutual-Human Model (UMHM). The proposed framework establishes three fundamental reward configurations: Mutual Reward, in which multiple artificial intelligence models generate, exchange, evaluate, and refine reward signals for one another; Human Reward, in which human individuals or groups independently provide reward judgments, preferences, evaluations, and reinforcement signals; and Mutual–Human Reward, in which artificial and human participants jointly contribute to reward generation and assessment. Unlike architectures that permanently rely on human feedback, exclusively employ AI-generated feedback, or combine reward sources through fixed weighting, AMHR introduces Adaptive Reward Mechanism Selection, Adaptive Reward Mechanism Switching, Adaptive Reward Combination, and Adaptive Reward Reconfiguration. A context-sensitive decision mechanism determines which reward configuration is appropriate according to reward reliability, model disagreement, uncertainty, task characteristics, human expertise, operational risk, computational resources, and the expected value of additional human participation. The framework further distinguishes reward generation, reward evaluation, reward calibration, reward aggregation, and reward utilization, preventing the assumption that generating a reward signal necessarily establishes its validity. Formal definitions, mathematical representations, an adaptive architecture, theoretical propositions, application scenarios, governance principles, and an empirical evaluation methodology are developed. To the best of our knowledge, this paper is the first to explicitly formulate a function-general, UMHM-grounded adaptive architecture that treats mutual rewarding among multiple large models and independent human rewarding as distinct but combinable operational configurations, with explicit adaptive selection, switching, combination, and reconfiguration. This is a narrowly defined theoretical novelty claim and does not assert that peer rewarding, RLHF, RLAIF, or AI-assisted reward modeling originated with this work. The proposed framework provides a conceptual foundation for developing intelligent systems that can move beyond dependence on a single reward source and dynamically organize artificial and human contributions according to the requirements of each task.
Authors
- Jincheng Zhang (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0005-1860-0009)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24362571
- Primary Topic
- Reinforcement Learning in Robotics
- Type
- preprint