Green means go: an ECG foundation model over-calls normal athletes, and athlete-criteria labels correct it
Objective To test whether a publicly released ECG foundation model respects the International Recommendations for ECG interpretation in athletes, and whether its errors can be corrected without athlete data. Methods We applied ECGFounder, trained on about 10 million hospital ECGs, to non-athletes with only training-related (“green”) findings (PTB-XL, Chapman/Ningbo) and to two athlete groups: 26 Norwegian endurance athletes read as normal by a cardiologist and 156 green-only recordings from 52 Spanish footballers. In a sequence of pre-registered steps we tested four fixes, anchoring sensitivity on screening-relevant abnormal ECGs, and confirmed the best fix with thresholds set on data it had never seen. Results Green-only ECGs were called abnormal in 33.7% of PTB-XL and 17.9% of Chapman/Ningbo cases, and the model called abnormal 34.6% of normal endurance athletes and 47.4% of footballer recordings, sometimes labelling infarction. Rules applied over the model’s own named findings, with or without measured intervals, made things worse. A small readout retrained on the model’s features with athlete-criteria labels, using non-athletes only, called 17.6% (95% CI 10.3% to 25.4%) of normal athletes abnormal against 52.8% for the model’s own output, at 87.5% against 89.4% sensitivity for screening-relevant abnormal ECGs, and held across three training seeds. Conclusion The model’s representation already separates athletic adaptation from disease; its default output does not. Relabelling the readout against the International Criteria removes about two-thirds of the false alarms.
Authors
- Chukwudi Samuel Eke (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0002-2294-673X)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11776488/v1
- Primary Topic
- ECG Monitoring and Analysis
- Type
- preprint