Chemically modified agricultural-waste adsorbents: a critical review of leaching, toxicity, regeneration, and end-of-life risks
Chemical modification (acid or alkaline treatment, metal-oxide impregnation, magnetization, oxidation, and surface functionalization) improves the adsorption performance of agricultural-waste adsorbents, but better performance does not establish environmental safety. This critical narrative review synthesized 54 sources, identified through targeted searching and citation tracking, around three questions: which modifications create leaching or toxicity risks, how adequately these risks are assessed, and what hazards arise during regeneration and end-of-life management. Risk claims were classified into explicitly defined evidence tiers. Risk depended more on regenerant chemistry, pH, aging, and dose than on modification type; iron loss from one magnetic biochar ranged from <0.05% to 70% depending on the regenerant. Modification reduced risk in some systems but created release or transformation risks in others. Ecotoxicity was rarely measured: 5 of 26 audited primary studies reported it, none alongside reusability, and most quantitative findings rested on single studies. Adsorption performance alone is insufficient evidence of environmental suitability. Priorities include pH-dependent and percolation leaching tests, multi-trophic bioassays, transformation-product analysis, per-cycle release reporting, and characterization of spent adsorbents before disposal or reuse.
Authors
- Francis Xavier Amo-Broni
- Michael Owusu Ofori
Institutions
- University of Education, Winneba (GH)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Essential Chem
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1080/28378083.2026.2764398
- Primary Topic
- Adsorption and biosorption for pollutant removal
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00