Predicting individual tree height in natural Pinus yunnanensis forests: a comparison of generalizability between parametric mixed-effects models and data-driven random forest

Accurate tree height prediction in natural forests requires integrating heterogeneous factors and capturing nonlinear relationships. We compared nonlinear mixed-effects (NLME) and random forest (RF) models for predicting individual-tree height of natural Pinus yunnanensis , identified key predictors, and explored pathways for integrating the two frameworks. We used data from 4,106 trees in 413 permanent plots in Yunnan Province, China, and included variables representing site quality, stand density and competition, stand structure, and climate; plots were split into training and independent test sets at a 70:30 ratio. The NLME model (based on the Hossfeld IV equation with plot-level random effects) included three statistically significant predictors: diameter at breast height (DBH), dominant height ( H d ), and temperature difference (TD). A full-variable RF (RF_full) used all features, whereas a reduced RF (RF_reduced) used the same three predictors to separate algorithm effects from variable-selection effects. Although both RF models fitted the training data better than the NLME model, this advantage did not transfer to independent plots: on the test set, the NLME model (RMSE = 1.66 m, MAE = 1.27 m, MAPE = 14.87%) achieved accuracy nearly identical to that of RF_full (1.66 m, 1.27 m, 14.86%) despite using only three predictors, clearly outperformed RF_reduced (1.75 m, 1.36 m, 16.06%), and produced more balanced residual distributions under heterogeneous plot conditions. The RF_reduced comparison confirmed that the advantage of NLME over RF_reduced arose from the explicit parametric structure with random effects rather than from variable selection. Within the sampled domain, adding features did not improve prediction on new plots: coupling plot-level random effects with a parametric growth equation matched RF_full while using only three predictors, with more stable and interpretable predictions. Because the training and test data were drawn from the same geographic domain, validation in other regions is warranted. We propose incorporating random effects into ensemble learning as cross-level structural constraints, shifting forest growth modeling from method comparison to method integration.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Frontiers in Plant Science
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2026.2001154
Primary Topic
Forest ecology and management
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Predicting individual tree height in natural Pinus yunnanensis forests: a comparison of generalizability between parametric mixed-effects models and data-driven random forest

Yangping Qin, 吴雪琼, Panpan Zhang, Yuan Feng et al.
Frontiers in Plant Science
Forest ecology and management
article

Predicting individual tree height in natural Pinus yunnanensis forests: a comparison of generalizability between parametric mixed-effects models and data-driven random forest

Yangping Qin, 吴雪琼, Panpan Zhang, Yuan Feng, Wei Liao, Chengcheng Zhang, Fei Zhang, Guanghui Dai
article en

Abstract

Accurate tree height prediction in natural forests requires integrating heterogeneous factors and capturing nonlinear relationships. We compared nonlinear mixed-effects (NLME) and random forest (RF) models for predicting individual-tree height of natural Pinus yunnanensis , identified key predictors, and explored pathways for integrating the two frameworks. We used data from 4,106 trees in 413 permanent plots in Yunnan Province, China, and included variables representing site quality, stand density and competition, stand structure, and climate; plots were split into training and independent test sets at a 70:30 ratio. The NLME model (based on the Hossfeld IV equation with plot-level random effects) included three statistically significant predictors: diameter at breast height (DBH), dominant height ( H d ), and temperature difference (TD). A full-variable RF (RF_full) used all features, whereas a reduced RF (RF_reduced) used the same three predictors to separate algorithm effects from variable-selection effects. Although both RF models fitted the training data better than the NLME model, this advantage did not transfer to independent plots: on the test set, the NLME model (RMSE = 1.66 m, MAE = 1.27 m, MAPE = 14.87%) achieved accuracy nearly identical to that of RF_full (1.66 m, 1.27 m, 14.86%) despite using only three predictors, clearly outperformed RF_reduced (1.75 m, 1.36 m, 16.06%), and produced more balanced residual distributions under heterogeneous plot conditions. The RF_reduced comparison confirmed that the advantage of NLME over RF_reduced arose from the explicit parametric structure with random effects rather than from variable selection. Within the sampled domain, adding features did not improve prediction on new plots: coupling plot-level random effects with a parametric growth equation matched RF_full while using only three predictors, with more stable and interpretable predictions. Because the training and test data were drawn from the same geographic domain, validation in other regions is warranted. We propose incorporating random effects into ensemble learning as cross-level structural constraints, shifting forest growth modeling from method comparison to method integration.

Frontiers in Plant ScienceVol. 17
Yunnan Academy of Forestry (CN)
Forest ecology and management
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon