Preventing Honor Killing Before the Lethal Act: The Limits of Reactive Criminal Law and the Case for Preventive Legal Governance
Honor killing raises a preventive problem when cumulative coercion and distributed participation become visible before the grounds for particular coercive powers are established. This article examines that problem through conceptual and normative legal analysis of honor-based abuse, forced marriage, homicide-prevention scholarship, and selected legal materials. It defines the pre-lethal governance gap as a failure to translate fragmented knowledge into an assigned, lawful, and reviewable protective response. Preventive legal governance is developed as an operational specification of existing due-diligence and safeguarding obligations, rather than a new duty to prevent violence. Its contribution lies in connecting the relational unit of preventive concern to the individualized justification required for each institutional act. Four overlapping risk configurations organize the model without implying an inevitable progression toward homicide. The analysis differentiates voluntary support, shared protective records, civil restrictions, and criminal investigation, each governed by distinct legal conditions. A Pre-Lethal Due Process Guarantee Framework specifies judicial control, meaningful opportunities to contest restrictions, limited duration, and periodic review. Evidentiary stewardship regulates information transfer, correction, retention, and erasure so that protective records do not become unofficial criminal histories. Victim agency informs the choice and timing of interventions, including the assessment of retaliation created by disclosure or unwanted action. The framework offers a normative basis for jurisdiction-specific development while making no claim to predictive validation or demonstrated preventive effectiveness.
Authors
- Zul Khaidir Kadir (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0001-7774-0790)
Institutions
- Universitas Muslim Indonesia (ID)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Journal of Law and Governance
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.64229/ktw7pf02
- Primary Topic
- Intimate Partner and Family Violence
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00