Developing a healthcare quality indicator system for integrated TCM and western medicine in Sichuan's tertiary public hospitals: a modified delphi-AHP study

Introduction In China, existing healthcare quality evaluation systems are predominantly designed for Western medicine-only (WM) or Traditional Chinese medicine-only (TCM) hospitals. Despite the rapid growth of integrated TCM-WM hospitals in Sichuan Province, no such evaluation framework exists for them. This study aimed to construct a candidate indicator system for assessing and enhancing integrated TCM-WM healthcare quality in tertiary public hospitals in Sichuan Province. Methods Based on Donabedian's Structure-Process-Outcome (SPO) theoretical model, an initial indicator pool was constructed by drawing on relevant literature, policies, and guidelines, along with group discussions. Indicators were screened via a two-round modified Delphi method and weights were determined using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). AHP consistency ratios (CR) were required to be <0.1. Expert consultation quality was assessed by the expert positivity coefficient, authority coefficient (Cr), and Kendall's W, with thresholds set at >70%, >0.70, and >0.1 ( P < 0.05), respectively. Results A 3-level evaluation system comprising three first-level, eight second-level, and 36 third-level indicators was constructed in two Delphi rounds. The expert consultation showed statistical significance: positivity coefficients exceeded 70%, Cr exceeded 0.70, and Kendall's W was significant (W > 0.1, P < 0.05). All consistency ratios (CR) were below 0.1. At the first level, process (A2) had the highest weight (0.3928), followed by structure (A1, 0.3321) and outcome (A3, 0.2751). At the second level, process management and control (B5, 0.2182) and quality control systems (B4, 0.1746) ranked highest. The top five third-level indicators were a quality control system covering the whole clinical pathway (C11, 0.0621), integrated TCM-WM ward round mechanism (C12, 0.0537), proportion of TCM physicians (C1, 0.0511), proportion of TCM pharmaceutical professionals (C2, 0.0498), and electronic medical record functional level (C8, 0.0472). Conclusions This study developed a candidate indicator system for evaluating integrated TCM-WM healthcare quality in tertiary public hospitals in Sichuan Province, with process and quality control indicators accounting for the largest weights. These findings provide a preliminary reference for quality improvement in integrated care settings. Its operability, validity, and generalizability remain to be empirically tested in future pilot studies.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Frontiers in Health Services
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/frhs.2026.1998124
Primary Topic
Delphi Technique in Research
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Developing a healthcare quality indicator system for integrated TCM and western medicine in Sichuan's tertiary public hospitals: a modified delphi-AHP study

Thammarat Marohabutr, Patreeya Kitcharoen, Seung Chun Paek, Daren Zhao
Frontiers in Health Services
Delphi Technique in Research
article

Developing a healthcare quality indicator system for integrated TCM and western medicine in Sichuan's tertiary public hospitals: a modified delphi-AHP study

Thammarat Marohabutr, Patreeya Kitcharoen, Seung Chun Paek, Daren Zhao
article en

Abstract

Introduction In China, existing healthcare quality evaluation systems are predominantly designed for Western medicine-only (WM) or Traditional Chinese medicine-only (TCM) hospitals. Despite the rapid growth of integrated TCM-WM hospitals in Sichuan Province, no such evaluation framework exists for them. This study aimed to construct a candidate indicator system for assessing and enhancing integrated TCM-WM healthcare quality in tertiary public hospitals in Sichuan Province. Methods Based on Donabedian's Structure-Process-Outcome (SPO) theoretical model, an initial indicator pool was constructed by drawing on relevant literature, policies, and guidelines, along with group discussions. Indicators were screened via a two-round modified Delphi method and weights were determined using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). AHP consistency ratios (CR) were required to be <0.1. Expert consultation quality was assessed by the expert positivity coefficient, authority coefficient (Cr), and Kendall's W, with thresholds set at >70%, >0.70, and >0.1 ( P < 0.05), respectively. Results A 3-level evaluation system comprising three first-level, eight second-level, and 36 third-level indicators was constructed in two Delphi rounds. The expert consultation showed statistical significance: positivity coefficients exceeded 70%, Cr exceeded 0.70, and Kendall's W was significant (W > 0.1, P < 0.05). All consistency ratios (CR) were below 0.1. At the first level, process (A2) had the highest weight (0.3928), followed by structure (A1, 0.3321) and outcome (A3, 0.2751). At the second level, process management and control (B5, 0.2182) and quality control systems (B4, 0.1746) ranked highest. The top five third-level indicators were a quality control system covering the whole clinical pathway (C11, 0.0621), integrated TCM-WM ward round mechanism (C12, 0.0537), proportion of TCM physicians (C1, 0.0511), proportion of TCM pharmaceutical professionals (C2, 0.0498), and electronic medical record functional level (C8, 0.0472). Conclusions This study developed a candidate indicator system for evaluating integrated TCM-WM healthcare quality in tertiary public hospitals in Sichuan Province, with process and quality control indicators accounting for the largest weights. These findings provide a preliminary reference for quality improvement in integrated care settings. Its operability, validity, and generalizability remain to be empirically tested in future pilot studies.

Frontiers in Health ServicesVol. 6
Mahidol University (TH), Sichuan Provincial Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine (CN)
Delphi Technique in Research
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon