The Necessity of Trial: Prefigurative Legalities, Strategic Formalism and the Affordances of the Trial
This paper explores the power of legal form in the absence of legal authority through a reading of American Trial: The Eric Garner Story (2020). Six years after a grand jury declined to indict New York Police Department Officer Daniel Pantaleo in relation to the death of Eric Garner, the film stages the trial that did not follow. Structurally aligned with court processes, American Trial presents a ‘trial’ of Pantaleo, using practising attorneys, real witnesses, actual evidence and legal procedure, but without the authority or jurisdiction of a court. The only featured professional actor in the film plays the defendant. Reading the film through prefigurative legality and Caroline Levine’s strategic formalism, this paper argues that it is the form of the trial that makes justice visible and imaginable through its ritual, aesthetic and performative affordances. American Trial creates a sense of witnessing justice through the public performance of legal procedure. American Trial reveals both the promise and the limits of appropriating legal form. There is an authority that emerges from the aesthetic, procedural and semantic features of the trial. Even in the absence of legal authority, the hierarchical, accusatory and punitive forces of the trial remain present.
Authors
- Dale W. Mitchell (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8712-9186)
Institutions
- University of the Sunshine Coast (AU)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Law Culture and the Humanities
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1177/17438721261503092
- Primary Topic
- Law in Society and Culture
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00