The General Practitioner as Institutional Polymath: A Hypothesis on What Artificial Intelligence Changes in Breadth, Depth and Integration
General practice asks ordinary practitioners to combine breadth across all health problems, depth in the field and in the continuing care of persons, and integration within the single consultation. Drawing on a recent triadic model of polymathy, in which breadth, depth and integration are jointly necessary and the term can refer to any system that displays them, this hypothesis paper proposes to describe the general practitioner as an institutional polymath: a role, rather than a person, whose defining documents require all three dimensions and whose training is designed to produce them in ordinary practitioners. In the author's reading of the twelve characteristics of the European Definition of General Practice/Family Medicine, breadth and integration are primary in several characteristics, depth is required both in the field and in the person, and no characteristic refers to digital or artificial intelligence (AI) tools. Drawing on evidence from general practice and from research on reliance on automated advice, the paper hypothesises that AI currently lowers the cost of stored breadth but not of integration or of checking, that the ability to detect wrong outputs depends on the practitioner's depth of medical knowledge, and that this depth may weaken with use of the tool. Studies in which AI systems matched or exceeded physicians, and a meta-analysis in which human-AI combinations performed, on average, worse than the better of the two, are discussed as counter-evidence. The central hypothesis is that competence for AI use in general practice is better described as maintaining the triad under new conditions than as a set of digital skills alone. The paper derives a specific prediction from the conjunctive model, an interaction between practitioner knowledge, AI support and the correctness of the suggestion, specifies five observations that would refute or narrow the hypothesis, and states eleven hypothesised competencies, each paired with an observation that would count against it. It makes no clinical recommendations and outlines a Delphi study and empirical tests.
Authors
- Florian Odilo Stummer (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6273-8014)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Preprints.org
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202611.1890.v1
- Primary Topic
- Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare and Education
- Type
- preprint